Skip to main content

Full text of "The Egoist Vol. 1 No. 21"

See other formats


Published the 1st and 15th of each month. 



The egoist 

AN TNDIVTDUALIST REVIEW. 



Formerly the NEW FREE WOMAN. 



No. 21.— Vol. I. 



MONDAY, NOVEMBER 2nd, 1911. 



Sixpence. 



Editor: HARRIET SHAW WEAVER. 
Assistant Editor: RICHARD ALDINGTON. 



CONTENTS. 



Page. 



Arm and Disarmament. By Dora 
Marsden ." 



Views and Comments 



Fighting Parts. 
Ciollcowska... 



By Madame 



401 
404 



405 



Page. 
The Songs op Maldoror. By the 

Comte de Lautreamont 409 

War Poetry. By John Gould 

Fletcher 410 

The Orange Symphony. By John 

Gould Fletcher 411 



Contributing Editor : 
DORA MARSDEN, B.A. 

Page. 

Art and Drama : Ibsen and 
Strindberg at War Time. By 
II untly Carter 412 

Preliminary Announcement op 

the College op Arts 413 

The Theatre. By John Rodker ... 414 

Correspondence 415 



ARMS AND DISARMAMENT. 

Bv Dora Marsden. 



r 



nHAT friendly twilight of inattention which even 
-*- the safest cause requires, the War lias rudely 
scattered for the disarmament propagandists. 
Au inconsiderate fate has flashed upon these would-be 
harmless people the critical light which looks to doc- 
trines only to judge of their application, and not at 
ali to the possibilities for unending delight in unenvi- 
able disputations which they possess. The cause of 
" disarmament," dragged forth for judgment in the 
presence of the undoctrinated, is compelled willy- 
nilly to state a case: and as far as the powers of its 
advocates hitherto have been able to make char it 
appears — just " a case " and nothing more. The pro- 
pagandists have been at no pains to put anything in 
it : the most elementary notions of their cause they 
have been content to leave sacred, which is 
unexamined. Disarmament has been apparently 
just, the slogan of a " cause" intending to imply no 
more than the pious application to international 
affairs of Mr. Watts' sentiment in regard to little 
children — little nations should agree and keep their 
angry passions down. Hence for light on disarma- 
ment one need not turn to the doctrines of the 
initiated : one must start from the, beginning and 
make shift for oneself. What are "arms," any- 
way? A dictionary says, "any mechanism which is 
set in motion from the shoulder," so that, disarma- 
ment would start with a surgical operation at the 
shoulder presumably. But no disarmer lias ever 
intended that : only annihilation of the means of 
attack and defence. What human arms are if not 
just these means in their ultimate sense is not clear, 
and the fact that all extensions of such means have 
been compendiously termed " arms," seems to leave 
them compromised to say the least. And thinking 
on the matter still more intently, one has to acknow- 
ledge that it must just have been the specific allocat- 
ing of limbs to the service of attack and defence as 
human arms, which raised one animal above all the 
rest, and created the human. The evolution of arms : 



the raising of the fore limbs in order to protect the 
more vulnerable head, and in order to add the weight 
and damage of paw and claw to that of fang, called 
into being, as it were incidentally, an animal which 
habitually stood upright: an animal which arms 
had made into a man. . . . But disarmers have 
found difficulties sufficiently numerous far nearer 
the threshold of their inquiry than " lopping from 
the shoulder" constitutes, and it is only "arms" 
external to the finger-tips which they would gladly 
see forbidden and destroyed, while scratching, 
hitting, kicking, biting, remain as offensives which 
must be allowed, because they may not be avoided 
therefore. Not fighting, but fighting with weapons 
is the bug-bear : and especially one is given to under- 
stand weapons which have working alliances with 
gunpowder. Someone who was writing recently on 
the subject kindly offered to explain why : to wit, 
"The common sense of the world to-day knows that 
if civilisation is to be preserved it must not rest on 
gunpowder." At first blush, to be sure, gunpowder 
does seem an uncertain seat for anything to rest on, 
but on thinking further one is struck by the fact that 
civilisation appears to select gunpowder, and that by 
a strong preference. It must, indeed, be singularly 
annoying to those whose common sense leads them 
to such an opinion as the one quoted, to have to 
observe how the more we have of gunpowder the 
more unmistakably does civilisation come into evi- 
dence. The sequence is constant enough to suggest 
the relation of cause and effect : gunpowder civilisa- 
tion. But many would prefer to call this mere coin- 
cidence. For the moment therefore, we may leave 
it, confident that even such will agree that that 
which they hold to be the opposite of civilisation, 
i.e., war fiercest war — did not wait for the advent of 
gunpowder to make its appearance. Nor even for 
the bow or the sword or the spear. Before the first 
stone was flung war was there. 



402 



THE EGOIST 



November 2, 1914 



Accordingly, if the aim of the diBarmer is to elimi- 
nate war, a restriction exercised according to the char- 
acter of weapons used will produce only illusory effects: 
since instruments capable of being used on the offensive 
— were their owners so minded as to use them — would 
include almost every instrument of utility and ornament: 
axe, club, scythe, bodkin, hairpin, the common arbiters 
of domestic polity, the poker and the boot, would all offer 
themselves at need in default of gunpowder. The 
ploughshare and pruning-hook, the often proffered anti- 
theses of weapms of offence could be relied upon to do 
effective damage were they the only weapons available 
in the field. Given pause for reflection, the genuine dis- 
armer may well begin to feel force and pertinence in the 
logic which starts disarmament .from the shoulder- 
socket, since almost anything that the human arm can 
wield for peaceful use it can wield equally well as a 
weapon of effective offence. He will begin to realise 
that it is not weapons but human temper which exerts 
the lure towards war, the undermining force of civilisa- 
tions: kinds of armaments are incidental; all that 
matters in regard to them being that they shall com- 
pete in effectiveness with those of the opponent. Their 
requisite character is purely relative. It is the spirit of 
war which is the absolute, and war is whenever there is 
antagonistic temper or desire for status or possessions. 
It is entirely a question of interests -the interwoven 
mesh of desires which net the antagonistic animus. 
Interests are the pride of life, and, given interests strong 
enough, men will use all and any arms they can come by 
for their furtherance. War itself — which is simply the 
active side of interests exerts the attraction of settling 
of the world's perspective to one's own liking, over and 
against that of the enemy, who endeavours to do a like 
thing on his own behalf. An enemy is not therefore a 
person whom one hates: he is a person one fights. It is 
unintelligent to hate hi in because he is an enemy, 
because it is precisely to be such that we have created 
him. He is a necessity of our combativeness. He is 
most profitably regarded a* the satisfaction of a primary 
want, like food or a lover. Our antagonisms arc teem- 
ing with vitality : they possess the vitalising hardness by 
resisting which we brace ourselves. It is a poor soul 
which must deprive itself the luxury of a good enemy. 
* * * * 
The fact that, civilised authorities discourage their 
peoples from having enemies except such as they them- 
selves duly authorise, goes a long way towards revealing 
the actual nature of civilisation, We quoted above a 
writer who believed that the common sense of the world 
opines there is something antagonistic between civilisa- 
tion and gunpowder (by which latter is meant, we may 
assume, armaments on the modern enormous scale). Yet, 
as we pointed out, the big gun has the appearance of 
being the greatly prolific progenitor of just those forms 
of society which we call civilised. And inevitably, settled 
peace is the display of force so unmistakably irresistible 
that it is not within the limits of possibility for the con 
quered powers to gainsay it. Force — a force that is— 
asserts and establishes itself. It is now, therefore, in 
the ascendant: it makes known its will: which is now 
the sole dominant will : it delineates its own conception 
of the forms its expressed will desires to take; that is, 
it outlines its species of order. It lays this conception of 
its order on the conquered, demanding for its execution 
an unquestioning obedience and for guidance in carry- 
ing it into being effectively and smoothly it frames laws. 
A law is a command accompanied by a threat, in case of 
refusal, to use all or any of the forces of compulsion 
which it is known or assumed are at the disposal of the 
framers. It can be taken for granted that a community 
in which the laws are accepted without question — which is 
highly civilised, that is — has its forces of compulsion in 
effective condition and well under the influence of those 
at whose inspiration the laws are made. To say that 
"the individual does not suffer in honour or interest 
because law has replaced violence in his social relation- 
ship," is to give evidence of complete incomprehension 
of the question at issue : law does not replace violence : 
it merely gives information detailing the manner in 



which violence will be directed. If one can manage to 
square one's honour and interest with the incidence of 
violence, well and good : if not, tant pis : one meets the 
violence. On this wise is the only authorised enemy of 
civilised society discovered to us, i.e., the flouter and dis 
Lurber of the "Law and Order" ordained by the para- 
mount : disturbers of the peace, which has been com- 
manded by the force which commands the most effective 
gunpowder. The gentle ways and modes of civilised 
society take rise in precisely the same manner as similar 
phenomena appear among children of astern parent who 
likes an ordered peace in his house and is powerful 
enough to see that he gets it. The children do not 
quarrel among themselves because "Father" finds it a 
confusion and an annoyance. Quarrelling upsets his 
"Order": the rebellious child is the domestic criminal. 



It is, therefore, easy to trace how the possession of 
forceful and successful arms affords to a great power 
(particularly in these modern times of enormous arma- 
ments, whose very enormity puts them beyond the pos- 
session of the people, and makes the State the obvious 
custodian) the basis upon which it can begin to build its 
particular brand of civilisation. Freed by its power 
from gainsaying both from without and within, such 
a State has leisure and authority to call into being an 
" Ordered Society," to become civilised that is. An 
ordered society means precisely what it says — a society 
which shapes itself in conformity with the orders given 
by the manipulators of the armed forces in its midst: 
orders which, described as laws, perforce the people 
must obey. For no large body of people, apart from 
unusual moments of danger, obey orders unless the pos- 
sibility to do otherwise does not lie in their possession. 
Such a condition of deficient power can only be effected 
by a body which is by comparison superiorly armed. A 
State possessing formidable and centrally-controlled 
armaments, with which the defensive weapons of those 
whose obedience is demanded cannot hope to compete, 
is precisely this body. Such a State commands just the 
conditions necessary to the laying down of orders which 
will effect peaceful submission between itself and its 
peoples, and if it so desires — and it usually docs — peace 
among the individuals one with another, whose differ- 
ences must be settled through its own appointed media. 
It can afford to take up the position that it will "stand 
no nonsense" in regard to disorder between individual 
and individual: can afford to insist on the regulation of 
social life by civil means, i.e., by means of vicarious 
violence. Individuals may settle and arrange matters 
among themselves only within limits: by verbal or 
written means. Violence remains the prerogative of 
the State. Such is the basis of civilisation, and it 
explains what civilisation is the expression of: i.e.. 
enforcement by violent compulsion of ways of settlement 
among a governed people who have been deprived of any 
power of gainsaying such external settlement by a 
previous deprival of arms. It is this settling of intra- 
individual affairs by civil means which is called Justice. 
"Civilisation must rest not upon gunpowder but upau 
Justice." Well, well: it amounts very much to the same- 
thing ! "T rest not upon this planet but upon this 
couch." Though civilisation depends upon Justice. 
Justice depends upon gunpowder, and civilisation there- 
fore depends upon gunpowder ultimately. It is, as a 
matter of fact, however, a favour allowed in charity to 
the rhetoricians to admit that civilisation rests upon 
Justice: Justice and civilisation — abstractions both at 
best — are not two things but one. Civilisation is rather 
related to Justice as a special case. It is Justice in 
limited and secondary application. Basic Justice is 
coincident with gunpowder. 



If, then, Justice fails the would-be disarmers : if Justice 
be not some transcendant and archetypal figure 
enthroned in the heavens before Earth or Time was, but, 
as far as civilisation is concerned, merely the internexus 
of guarantees for contracts of which the nature is condi- 
tioned by the arbitrament of arms, on what other 



November 2, 19U 



THE EGOIST 



403 






supports may disarmament fall back? Two for their 
support have been furnished: a rationalist and a theo- 
cratic: the authority of "The World" and of "God."' 
Both are passionately espoused, and naturally, for sup- 
port for a task stupendous and baffling cannot be lightly 
foregone. Note what Ihe task is on which the disarmers 
have set their hearts: it is the acquiring of supreme 
instruments of compulsion in order to overcome compul- 
sion while yet anathematising compulsory instruments. 
They would themselves compel all men else to believe 
thai compulsion is " wrong." Hitherto compulsion has 
always led to armaments, but what now when compul- 
sion would compel towards disarmaments? If all 
others are to be compelled not to arm at all, some 
authority must arm itself very efficiently. The power 
which undertakes to abolish Napoleonism will need to 
be very greatly and grandly Napoleonic. So this thing 
runs in a circle: Napoleonism is ever under the curse yet 
ever triumphant, ever to be brought under the heel yet 
ever on the heights. Hence the attempt to create a 
Napoleonic power which need fear no rival: The Worbl, 
It is odd how at every great erisis "reason " reverts to 
this fetish of "The World versus The Recalcitrant": odd 
because in every' attempt to apply it "The World" 
itself furnishes the subversive elements which make the 
rebel triumphant; "The World," in fact, cannot be the 
Super-Napoleon because "The World" cannot hang 
together. Napoleonism represents a progressive 
cohesion, while " The World" is the loose and disparate 
sum-total of disintegrating differences. It is unable to 
cohere : a poor opponent, therefore, for even a lilliputian 
Napoleon. One is compelled to realise that "The 
World" docs not mean what it would imply, hut relics 
for its hnpressis r eness upon its good comprehensive, 
sound. On a closer scrutiny "The World " appears one 
of those all inclusive generalisations which mean 
nothing because they aspire to mean everything. What 
does *' The World " mean to any of us? Who stands for 
"The World "? One could almost as readily develop a 
partisan ardour in favour of a constellation as become 
enthusiastic over "The World." Even the religions 
which were founded to "save" "The World" in order 
to wake an interest were compelled to split it up to 
furnish a portion which could be assigned to damnation. 
Tn fact, interest can live only upon difference, and those 
who have argued that because out of "The World" 
many States have leen carved they can, therefore, by a 
simple process of addition, collect the States together 
and obtain for "The World" the united coercive, power 
of all the States' " virtues " in order to annihilate in each 
all their particular vices, and all to the glory of the 
unified creation called "The World." have strayed 
lamentably in their reckoning. States are States 
(nationalities if one prefers so to call them), not because, 
they are alike but because they arc different. They 
exist not to accommodate what their neighbours consider 
their virtues, but the traits they consider their vices. 
All splits take place in order to allow the vices of the 
secessionists a better run. Adding secessionists (i.e., 
States) together to make a unified "World " can only 
be expected to prochice effects procurable by mixing 
together, say, saltpetre with sulphur and charcoal: a 
nasty explosion. A nation acquires its dominant charac- 
teristics far more by what it excludes than by what it 
includes, and to this extent it is the embodied expression 
of the motive which is common to any other form of 
grouping. A group is formed in order to keep out the 
crowd: as in the case of club membership, of which it is 
precisely its powers of exclusion which distinguishes it 
from the fair-ground or the street- 
# * * # 

The rationalist notion of an all-coercing "world- 
power" affords an excellent example of the floundering 
of cantatists. With all their desire to hit upon a fine- 
sounding justification for this strange new passion of 
great States for small ones, their wits seize upon all the 
fakes and omit the sole genuine one, i.e., that their lives 
in human nature an instinct which renders involuntary 
admiration to the small power putting its fortunes to the 
risk in order to rise: that there exists in men an involun- 



tary admiration for the signs of growth. While it is a 
misleading folly to encourage small States to believe that 
they have any justification except such as they can assert 
at the sword's point, it is an equal folly not to calculate 
that a small State putting up a likely fight to ease its 
growing pains will exercise, an enormous pull on the 
affections of the onlooker: not, of course, so much with the 
elderly party in authority whose interests its insurrec- 
tionary activity is flouting — but with the bystanders. 
Otherwise there is no justification for small States apart 
from the fact that their existence serves the interests of 
a greater by whose will alone they are enabled to live. 

* * * * 

Small States might, indeed, be considered as the 
women in international polity. As with women, their 
status is not defined at first hand by their own intrinsic 
strength: they find their value in the fact that their 
existence chances to be useful to some other power who 
on this account accords them a courtesy status. Their 
" rights " are in virtue of the needs of the mightier, and 
arc enjoyed by permission until such changes take place 
in the hang of things as may make their continued 
existence unnecessary: whereupon their "rights" 
shrivel to the dimensions of their virtual merits: to their 
might. For instance, the right of Denmark, Belgium, and 
Holland to exist lies in the fact that their existence as 
buffers is very useful to England. Their "rights" will 
dwindle very materially should Germany to whom their 
existence is the reverse of a necessity — become the 
superior power: a fact which the King of the Belgians 
is doubtless very well aware. 

* * * * 

Accordingly, this creation of the "World" as supreme 
authority possesses little with which to attract men who 
have not the itch for airing theories in newspapers. They 
do not incline towards investing it with coercive powers 
strong enough to reduce all other powers to a state of 
feebleness at which resistance becomes impossible. With 
a man of Mr. Roosevelt's tempera?7ient matters will 
appear different. Mr. Roosevelt elects to put the 
nostrum " The World versus the Recalcitrant" under his 
patronage, and it is ill-luck that contemporary history 
should so blatantly thrust forward its refuting commen- 
tary. 

» * * * 

Mr. Roosevelt calls for a world-police which shall 
secure the peace of the world ... to supplement and 
make effectual "a world agreement among all civilised 
and military powers to back righteousness by force." It, 
should be "solemnly covenanted that if any nation 
refused to abide by the decision of such a court the 
others would draw the sword on behalf of peace and 
justice, and would unitedly coerce the recalcitrant 
nation." Now, what save the adhesion of the United 
States to the side of the Allies is missing from this 
picture of a world-agreement backing " righteousness by 
force " in the state of affairs existant to-day. The 
"World" minus the United States is coercing recalcitrant 
Germany: with what ultimate effect it still lies too far 
within the veil of the future to see. But if Mr. Roosevelt 
imagines that the stepping in of the United States would 
make the desired difference and change the existing 
bloody spectacle into one of friendly peace one would 
make bold to say that he is enormously mistaken, for the 
reason that though he calculates the number of heads he 
miscalculates human nature. The spectacle of Germany 
to-day facing her enemies — Belgium under her foot, 
France held with her teeth, her right arm holding 
Russia and her left England, while from far beyond 
she can catch the swelling sound of foes trooping 
from every continent, Japan, Canada, Australia, India, 
South Africa. New Zealand— is tolerably heroic. Should 
the United States ally itself with Germany's enemies 
(if for the sake of illustration such a combination may be 
contemplated), then whether because of the fact that 
" Germany against the World " is too heroic a figure for 
human pride to tolerate her annihilation without a suffer- 
ing from its own Belf-contempt; or whether because of a 
certain sympathy which always lurks in the under-world 
for the bravely beaten; or because of a new-born 



404 



THE 



jealously of the world-power itself when freed of its most 
serious rival— on account of some or all of these causes 
" Germany against the World " will prove that the World 
is a less formidable foe for Germany than the present 
combination of the Allies. The Alliance swollen with the 
adhesion of the United States would be far more likely to 
tip over on the right side for Germany than the existent 
Alliance. The disintegrating forces of the enormous col- 
lectivity — The. World — would begin to dissolve out of it, 
and to its own detriment. 

* * * * 

The concept of the "World'' in addition to that of 
" Justice " both proving illusory as forces towering liigh 
above national and Imperial gunpower, what is there 
existent over and above the State powerful enough to 
compel the pugnacious ones to fall back in contented 
mediocrity and love? Nothing save the guns of one State 
to silence the other. The query presents a problem for 
human ingenuity, and this latter has not failed of a 
solution for lack of making attempts of which the con- 
ception of the theocratic State, the State coerced by Moral 
Suasion: by the Ghostly Police: by the Inner Voice: by 
the God over All, remains alive and paramount. 

* * * * 

The vision of the King of Kings, whose vice-regent is 
Conscience, whose Ambassador is the Inner Voice, and 
whose ordinances are " Right," is the most audacious as 
well as the most subtle effort of human ingenuity: it is 
so ingenious that one might say "ought" to "work." 
It. Hoes work exquisitely and impressively in rhetoric. 
There is one voice only against it: that of experience. 
Unfortunately that voice is decisive: because it is in 
experience that the scheme is required to work. And 
therein the Omnipotent One is quite notably powerless. 
All experience has to tell of how the Omnipotent is 
worsted. His incursion iuto practical matters is there- 
fore limited to an invocation of the " Great Name." He 
can scarcely attain even to the establishment of an iden- 
tity. Men commandeer their enemies' God as their own 
devil, while in complementary return they may see their 
Own similarly installed among the enemy and Jehovah 
interchanges with Baal. A like impotence is to be 
observed of the Omnipotent's Ambassador — the Inner 
Voice. It fails to make sound just where in its own 
interests its self-assertion is vital. Tt makes itself heard 
just where it can matter little whether it speaks or remains 



silent. Its purpose being to restrain the Napoleons, it 
yet flourishes only in the non-Napoleons: a Napoleon 
being by definition one constitutionally incapable of 
hearing an Innei Voice. The spell of two thousand 
years of Christianity has its testimony to add to the 
evidence of other theocracies: i.e., that its gospel is 
powerful as a working principle with the powerless. 
* # * * 

Christians are not, however, to be dismayed because 
their creed works only by opposite in experience: if 
experience fails to embody the theocracy, so much the 
worse for experience. Experience, i.e., the tale of the 
world, the flesh and the devil — must be repudiated: 
ignored by a World-authority established in a Kingdom 
beyond the World. Christianity sets forward with un- 
diminished energies to win the "world" for Christ. 
Intelligently it makes a bid for men's hearts, intelli- 
gently, because there the egoistic desires which cause all 
wars are born. The Christ is for peace and desires born 
of hearts that are Christ's must faint at birth. By 
negating desire the rivalry born of the struggle to satisfy 
desire, is forestalled. In order to fight greatly one needs 
must desire greatly. At that low-toned level at which 
one has little enough of desire as to be ready to suffer all 
violence and yet to offer none, one has arrived at the 
crux of the disarmament question. A theocracy, there- 
fore, of the Christian cast accepted by all the world 
is undoubtedly its one solution. Since Christianity 
beseiges and seeks to conquer the Force whose power is 
above the State, prior to it, and has the shaping of all 
States and all secessions from States which make up 
"the World,'" Christ conquers the World: He silences the 
desires of men in which lurks the power which towers 
high above all States. These, silenced, the warring cries 
which accompany the ever fluctuating struggle of mien 
with men and Slate with State will be hushed. The 
peace which indeed passeth all human understanding 
since it is the peace of the grave holds sway: a Thought 
without a thinker reigns silently over Nothingness. Dis- 
armament more drastic than that which starts from the 
socket is accomplished: it has started from the heart. 
When the heart has been drugged no need remains for 
lopping off the arm. The dilemma has been evaded and 
all other dilemmas with it. . . . Otherwise Napoleonism 
reigns supreme: its efficient moderator is a world of 
Napoleons with whom desire is great and rampant. 



VIEWS AND COMMENTS. 



IT may seem a long way from gunpowder to politeness, 
which, for most people, is a synonym for civilised 
dealing. To explain civilisation without explaining 
politeness is, for them, to leave civilisation unexplained: 
as though one should consider the art of the sculptor to 
finish with the blasting of the block-marble, without 
concern for the chisel-work which actually constitutes 
its distinctive character. Yet blasting and chiselling 
are parts of the one process, though the one is prior to 
the other: and gunpowder and politeness stand in a like 
relation to civilisation. Before men became material 
suitable for polishing, Tor civilising, they needs must be 
reduced to maniable conditions by harsher methods of 
treatment: and it is primarily this prior reduction which 
separates the civilised from the barbarian. 

* * # * 

The barbarian is the outsider: the one which has not 
begun to be submitted to the polishing process of a 
specific order. Thus, there is nothing absolute about 
barbarian or civilised: always it is a matter of point of 
view: it is the outsider which is the "barbarian" from 
the outsider's point of view. No race can appear bar- 
barians to themselves, because, from their point of view, 
they are insiders: that is, they have been submitted to 
the particular dominating power which governs them. 

* # * * 

Accordingly, it is not an accident which makes polite- 
ness an accompaniment of any strongly established class, 



and boorishness a trait found, if found, in the dominated. 
Politeness is the progressive utilisation of the subjected 
material in the manner to which the nature of subjected 
material most readily lends itself. It is an intelligent, 
adaptation of means to ends, once the great assumption 
of subjection has been accepted as a fact. Politeness is 
the smooth gloss which disguises precisely this fact: 
boorishness is its painful obtrusion through the smoothly- 
spread veneer. " To bury the hatchet," " to let sleeping 
dogs lie," is the sentiment which animates politeness 
and civility. The intent being to secure smooth working 
for the dominant and a soothed complacence in the 
dominated. It serves so well that, it always achieves 
good repute among those who create good reputations, 
i.e., among the dominant, and so manages to get an over- 
whelming amount of prestige behind it. According as 
the sense of class remains sound among the dominant, its 
observance towards inferiors is regarded as </<• riijitcW'. 
The sentiment of noblesse obUge is one of the exigences of 
healthy dominant-class interests. Among equals polite- 
ness is merely a convenience of variable utility. For the 
dominated it presents a different aspect. Its exercise 
is based upon a soother complacence, an instinct for 
safety, whereas boorishness is a kicking against the 
pricks. It is disliked by the dominant because of its 
inconvenience, while it is despised by the dominated 
because of its futility. It is the harping on the existence 
of a sore which cannot be healed, but which may be 
forgotten or ignored: it is a refusal to accept with grace 



November 2, 1914 



THE EGOIST 



40J 



what cannot be resisted with effect: it is the attribute 
of the " grouser " and " kill-joy," achieving all the pains 
but not the joys of the rebellious. The " little less," 
by which the boorish fall short of effectual reassertion, 
makes himi just something iess than even an unsuccessful 
rebel: it is merely a satisfaction of temper to no purpose, 
and it looks unintelligent because it. succeeds only in 
defeating itself and proclaiming its defeat. President 
Kruger represents one thing: but. General Keyers, might, 
one say, represents something considerably less: they arc 
the rebel and the boor. The difference is constituted by 
the difference in their chances of success. 

* * W « 

"Civilised dealing" with the dominated then is the 
extended application of the fact: that every condition of 
things has a better and a worse side according to the 
spirit in which one accepts it: the spirit which seeks to 
find in all things — compensfitions. With the dominant, 
on the other hand, it is the realisation that compensation 
for the dominated must be emphasised at all costs. For 
both, it is the utilisation of that dual aspect of appear- 
ances which makes them' appear the right side upwards 
which ever way they fall. On this same duality, "good " 
manners are based as well as diplomacy and sound polity. 
For, if there are " Overs" there must be " Unders ": and 
each will distil from its condition its own comfort: 
diplomacy is the sensitive touch which feels for the 
fitting one to be brought into relief at the apposite time, 
•a * * *- 

It is a limited intelligence which can "tell the tale " 
only in one way. An intelligence has not grasped the 
simple elements of any situation until it can tell it forth 
in at least two; even the dual-telhng process itself must 
be described dually as Duplicity or Diplomacy as the 
case needs. It is part of the weight of stupidity which 
seems to settle upon civilised States when they become 
afraid of the sound of the words 'duplicity" and 
" diplomacy " while yet enlarging on the merits of 
civilisation. Such fear plainly argues that they have 
become the victims of the particular form of duplicity 
which constitutes civilisation — have lost their way, in 
fact, between one story and another. It seems that the 
cloak of civilisation, to secure to its wearers its advan- 
tages and yet to prove innocuous to them, must perforce 
carry a "barbarian" lining. The outcry for frankness 
from the upholders of civilisation is like the plaint of 
one who thinks he is bent on a good game of cards 
though he clamour for a preliminary exposure of the 
players' hands. Polite, civilised society means a society 
which tacitly disavows frankness. Civilisation deals in 
superficialities only, but is none the less important for 
that. Nine-tenths of the experiences of life work their 
course out along a surface of superficialities, and it is 
as absurd to depreciate superficialities as it would be 
to despise the surface of the earth: one can appreciate 
the value of the external crust and yet remain cheerful )y 
aware that a few thousand miles within the crust condi- 
tions are distinctly different, and that if one is going to 
have to do with these interior conditions quite other 
preparations will need to be taken from those which arc 
necessary for activities on the surface. So, politeness— 
the methods of civilisation — fare well enough within the 
limits of a fixed and accepted status: within the orbits 
that is of recognised State Orders, but where these, 
themselves are in question the cry for "civil" methods 
is simply absurd. 

* * # # 

The evidence of the stupidity's existence among our 
over-civilised of to-day the stupidity which is innocuous 
only when limited to the claque, but quite seriously under- 
mining when it spreads to the dominant-class, is not 
confined to such niaiscries as "equal rights " as between 
the civil and military castes, or between men and women ; 
it emerges, unconscious and unfaked, in complete unmis- 
takability in the democratic demand for an "open" 
Foreign Policy: for a complete diplomatic explicitncss. 
"Diplomatic explicitness " is an amusing combination if 
it is examined well enough: a direct contradiction, in 
fact, being an "unfolded folding-together." A para- 



mount Imperial foreign policy, of necessity, is diplo- 
matic, duplex, making great show of one set of cards in 
order to keep rival suspicions asleep as to the existence 
of those on which she actually relies for success. A 
"frank" statement of what an Imperial Foreign Office 
seeks to establish and maintain in its foreign relations 
would prick into activity just that sleeping pride of 
foreign nations which it has been the burden of its 
labours to lull. Imperial " frankness," far from avoiding 
war, would bring an Empire's rival buzzing about its 
ears with the animus of a disturbed nest of wasps. On 
the other hand, diplomatic " frankness " on the part of 
an ambitious "rising" State would find its analogy in, 
and would receive the treatment accorded to, the boorish- 
ness of the private individual. A rising nation requires 
to be actually "risen" before it can be diplomatically 
frank (*.e., dispense with diplomacy) with safety. 
Unless a nation is in a position to fight so irresistibly as 
to command a frankness to match its own, it must needs 
match guile with guile. Otherwise it is likely to find 
half the world arrayed against it: which is not a healthy 
sign, but one which argues erudeness and unfamiliarity 
with the ways of dominating power. In short, a nation's 
policy can safely be "frank" only when it is practically 
certain of the issue in reverting to that '.' extension of 
policy" which is an appeal to force, and there exist 
grounds for so many miscalculations in regard to the 
issues of force that even then diplomacy can be laid 
aside only with reserve. The susceptibilities of the 
stupid making up nine-tenths of Public Opinion: the 
diplomacy of those who own even the biggest battalions 
will need to keep a reverting eye to that. In these days of 
a world-extended Press particularly, though in war the 
sword is still supreme, arbiter, the number of times it 
must strike can be enormously increased by effects due 
to scratches of the pen. If, for instance, Napoleon had 
been proclaimed world-ruler in advance of his insidious 
growth, his warned and alarmed foes would have 
scotched his career before Napoleonism had the chance 
to work itself out. But it became established long before 
the world was half aware what a Napoleon was. A pre- 
acclaimed Napoleon has a task before him infinitely 
larger than ever was Napoleon's. 

D. M. 



FIGHTING PARIS. 

September, 25.— There is a spring at the back of this 
country which spares it from all definite calamity. 
Attempted conquests of the country have benefited no 
one and never will. The French do not need or want the 
foreigner at the best of times; but when he forces his 
•way in . . . beware. There is no nation in the world 
that will resist the invader more vehemently. The 
Frenchman wants bis house to himself; the French 
nation wants its country to itself. From the height of 
his lonely pinnacle M. Anatole France, intoxicated, no 
doubt, by the scope of his pseudonym, takes upon him- 
self to make, in the name of the country, a declaration 
of friendship towards the Germans. He writes to the 
at one time internationalist, now jingoist, M. Reive (of 
all people): " When we shall have vanquished their 
last army and reduced their last fortress, we will pro- 
claim that the French people admits the beaten enemy 
into its friendship." M. Anatole France belongs to a 
certain sect generally called humanitarian and pacifist 
(more locally " Dreyfusard ") and in M. de Mun's polite 
academic language "wild dreamers" who, not being 
able to ask us just at this point to open our arms to the 
invader, " turn their eyes towards the future when they 
hope to resume the ludicrous dreams for which we now 
pay so dearly." If so they must be thanked for it, for 
since they could not prevent this or any other war they 
have rendered a service by provoking it at a time pro- 
pitious to those countries more directly interesting us, — 
but also let it not be forgotten that it is to the party they 
support that we owe the earlier defeats and the viola- 
tion of the country. That is where pacifist and 
humanitarian ideas lead. 




406 



THE EGOIST 



November 2, 1914 



It is this party which has so lung opposed all expendi- 
ture on the army, the construction of forts, three years' 
service, etc. I think it ought to "lie low" and not 
throw itself in the name of the country at the head of 
the Germans, making cheap its friendship before it has 
been asked for. But M. France is crying in a wilderness 
with M. Gustavo Herve, socialist and ex-paeifist, 
revolutionary and internationalist, atheist and oppor- 
tunist, as his only echo. 

September 28. — This night we were awakened by a 
cannon — a long rumbling, really beautiful sound — at 
comparatively close quarters. Then we discerned 
occasional repeated muffled shots as of rifles. What the 
object was is a mystery to us at present. To Paris. On 
the Boulevard dc Clichy I noticed a gathering of people 
outside a small cafe. On investigation I found the centre 
of attraction was a Belgian soldier whom I at first took 
for a German owing to the similarity in the helmet, lie 
was talking to a priest. Tt is noticeable that the priest 
has regained a certain prestige during this war ; for 
some indefinable reason he takes his place naturally by 
the soldier's side. — Paris becomes very beautiful and 
mysterious at night-time with its lack of light. — 
Wounded soldiers are becoming so common that the 
attention they at first attracted decreases from day to 
day. A wounded tirailleur from Algeria on the boat this 
evening did not provoke the slightest interest. — I was 
told that some people I know have been visiting the 
battlefields. You are given the authority to do this on con- 
dition you are prepared to bring back whatever corpses 
or other human remains are entrusted to you. They 
discovered several crucified bodies as also corpses of 
women on whom acts of violence had been committed. 
I add this information as it was given me (regretfully) 
to the published report about an English officer having 
been crucified by German soldiers. Otherwise I have 
no desire to enlarge upon "atrocities." 

September 20. — Comment in "La Liberte " upon an 
artillery man's letter: "France will, indeed, owe eternal 
gratitude to the inventors of our 75 (gun) as also to the 
inventor of menelite." Wonderful weather. 

September 30.— News curtailed to the extreme. We 
seem again to be left very much in the dark and have to 
be satisfied with "there is no change to report in the 
battle " which began a fortnight, ago. — The drummer 
passes to say that anyone who wants to learn to knit 
jerseys for the soldiers need only apply at the town-hall 
where lessons and worsted are supplied free to appli- 
cants ! It is to be hoped that by the time novices will 
be sufficiently expert in knitting the fighting will be 
over. Meanwhile those who can knit do and you see 
busy needles everywhere in the trains, trams, boats, etc.. 
just as in England ! Fortunately, there are people suffi- 
ciently provided with sense and money to buy the jerseys 
ready-made and have them sent at once to the front. — 
The talk in Paris is that the French forces are in con- 
stant progression and that the Germans have proposed 
to penetrate into Switzerland and envelop the French 
army from that direction. I was shown a letter from a 
soldier — a poet in peace-time — to a mutual friend say- 
ing he had not received a single communication since he 
left for his regiment in the first days of August. Yet 
letters have been repeatedly sent. He tells of nights 
spent in the open, sleepless because of the cold, 
beginning never before ten and ending at three in the 
morning. — Among writers and artists either at the front 
or in some kind of military service are, or have been, 
Jacques and Marcel Boulanger, Jacques Nayral, Jean 
de Pierrefeu (of " L' Opinion ") ; Guy-Charles Cros .: 
Andre Dunoyer de Segonzac ; Bernard Naudin : 
Alexandre Mercereau ; Mario Meunier ; Jean Variot ; 
Roger Allard ; Francis de Croisset, Marcel Prevost, 
Eugene Marsan. Louis Thomas, Jean-Louis Vaudoyer, 
F. R. Vanderpyl, Fernand Roches, editor of " L'Art 
Decoratif " ; Henry Bordeaux, — and how many others ! I 
give these names as they occur to me. Some are volun- 
teers. Guy de Cassagnac, the journalist and son of the 
famous nationalist Paul de Cassagnac, has been killed in 
the field. M. Anatole France, aged seventy, in con- 
sideration of the hostile reception accorded to his recent 
declaration, proposes to make amends for it by changing 



his friendly attitude towards the enemy into an aggres- 
sive one and bearing arms in place of olive branches. 
M. Bernard Grasset, the publisher, is in the fighting 
ranks and has presented 500 volumes from his stock to 
the Red Cro.s.s Society.— Gahriele d'Annunzio is, I hear, 
writing a journal <if his experiences in Paris during the 
war. 

Ootobeb 2. Paris at night is always beautiful, but 
never has it been bo beautiful as it is now without lights. 
This evening the city was bathed in a delicate mist which 
further contributed to the mystery of the scene. Against 
the darkened banks of the river the little steamers stood 
out brilliant like glow-worms, and as all outline was 
effaced the lights in the houses hung in the atmosphere 
like stars in the sky or the bright spots in a picture, by 
Whistler. The blazing shafts of the search-lights intro- 
duced the Martian, modern element. It now transpires 
that when the Germans were within a day's march of 
Paris General Gallieni saved the situation by mustering 
all the available taxi cabs, filling them with soldiers and 
sending them post haste to reinforce the defences out- 
side the city. All night long they dashed out of the town 
and this explains the sudden disappearance of taxis 
from the Paris streets on the 31st August. 

October 3. — The sound of guns reaches us frequently 
this afternoon. It may be due to exercises. The Egoist 
being, fortunately, a journal in which such reference 
can be made without suspicion of quackery or lunacy 
accruing to me, I may be allowed to call attention in its 
columns to the prophecies of a famous palmist, called 
Mine, de Thebes, as published in her Alnianach this last 
winter, wherein she predicted the death of the Pope, of 
the editor of the - ' Temps," the landslips which occurred 
in Paris this spring, the Caillaux case, the war, nol le 
speak of her mention of the beautiful weather which 
would prevail throughout the season and notably favour 
the more tragic episodes. "Paris in the coming year," 
she wrote in 1913, " will see moments both tragic and 
sublime." She remarks upon the signs of change anil 
tragedy she had noticed in the hands of people living 
in Eastern France where she foresaw "burning towns." 
She distinguished, also, a current of idealism sweeping 
over the land " like a flame." "Fire against fire. The 
one destructive, the other constructive, and above all 
this the stooping shades of women, great deeds of love 
and charity. . . . Then, in Paris, days of public mourn- 
ing and days, more numerous, of joy. Commands 
directed far off, even beyond the frontier." In the 
North of France, existing conditions, she writes, will be 
interrupted then resumed again. There will be more 
than one capital, she says precisely. Then she takes 
foreign countries one by one. Beginning with Italy she 
foresees that the " attention of the whole world will be 
centred on Italy during the supreme hours." Germany 
she finds replete with alarming symptoms; "the crest 
the Emperor bears on his helmet is not an eagle of vic- 
tory." As for Austria, she announced the murder of the 
Archduke in her previous Almanach, and reiterates it 
here adding numerous calamities. Her considerations on 
Belgium conclude with the phrase : " Poor little country ! 
Poor little court! All are doomed." For England she 
predicts " war within and without " in those exact words. 
I'ufortunately she also mentions "flood or some other 
catastrophe due to water, affecting London especially, 
and which will fill the world with pity." It must be 
recalled than in Mme. de Thebes' calculations the year 
does not begin on the 1st of January to end on the 31st 
of December, but concludes with the winter and begins 
with the spring. 

Ootobeb 4. —A bright Paris Sunday. The streets are 
animated, the Luxembourg gardens full of cheerful 
promenews. The neighbourhood of Montparnasse is 
multi-coloured with native soldiers, immensely tall, 
black as night, often wounded, wearing linen bloomers 
and with yards of red sash about their waists. To a 
friend's whom I found busy making chest-protectors and 
handkerchiefs for soldiers. For the former she takes 
pieces of material from old dresses of any colour, lining 
them with flannel or flannelette. The result is excellent ; 
the cost only the trouble. 



November 2, 1914 



THE EGOIST 



407 



October 5. — An excursion east of Paris to Champigny 
a. .junction through which pass numerous troop trains 
on their way North from the East — took me through the 
woods of Vincennes, an important military centre, par- 
ticularly active just now. The entrance is strongly 
guarded with barbed wire and cut trees. One part has 
been fenced oft' for the herding of cattle prior to their 
being sent to the front for the soldiers' rations. The 
fort of Vincennes recalls the Tower of London, both 
architecturally and on account of the use made of it. 
Rows of armed soldiers guarded the entrance where 
crowds were waiting to sec "Black Marias" bring in- 
visible prisoners of war. The whole neighbourhood was 
humming with busy soldiery ; while sailors, a girl on each 
arm, were ubiquitous too. The approach to Champigny 
station was thickly peopled with onlookers from the capi- 
tal and the neighbourhood who had come with camp stools 
to wait for the arriving trains. Inside the open station 
a committee privately formed distributes bread, (lowers 
— of course ! — wine and so forth to the passing trains, 
and outside the people band to them whatever bounties 
they have brought on their own account. Every now 
and again a member of the committee lounged along the 
separating fence on the look-out for trifles — like the 
animals in the Zoo that prowl up and down their netting 
to beg for buns. Hawkers sell pommes >le terre friies, and 
postcards for the soldiers' correspondence which the 
public buys and hands over the fence afterwards. Notices 
in the names of the army surgeons ask for fruit for the 
wounded. Two boy scouts— one of whom is, 1 was told, 
about to be decorated by the Minister of War for un- 
usual zealousncss in the interests of the wounded — sit at 
a table and seem chiefly responsible for the com- 
missariat department and distribution of the indis- 
pensable flowers. (A French soldier will cling to a posy 
all through a day and I saw one make a rush across 
the platform at the risk of missing his train to snatch a 
bunch). The war will, for the first time., have revealed 
to the French the resources of the small boy. The boy- 
scouts are being employed for a variety of tasks and 
make themselves unexpectedly useful. Up to now the 
French boy was a poor, over-worked, over-fed, under- 
exercised, over-chaperoned creature, utterly superflous 
and aimless in the world outside his stuffy classroom, 
and without any purpose in life save that of furnishing 
his brain with knowledge (of all kinds) to be made use 
of in his adult days, — a nuisance to himself and to others. 
It seemed as though the French could not produce such 
a thing as a decent boy (it is true the English held the 
monopoly). All of a sudden— such are the resources of 
this surprising country — someone (to name him, 
Monsieur Cheradame, a well-known figure in political 
journalism) took upon himself to acclimatise the boy- 
scout idea among his countrymen. The name and 
uniform were all ready, — with these the French can do 
anything; without, little. In a very short time the idea 
had "taken' 1 and thousands of boys were enrolled 
under the title of " Eclaireurs de France." Then, of 
course, there sprang up a rival body, to the benefit of 
both as is always the case. The small boys of France 
have at last found an aim in life outside school-books 
and mischief; the conscience, independence, initiative, 
camaraderie and other necessary corollaries sprang 
into being as though by enchantment. The boy did not 
make the scout, the scout made the boy. The title was 
the magic word ; the costume the magic gown. The 
French boy has become as clean-faced, as clean-minded 
as the best of English boys. He exists at last; he justi- 
fies himself. Such are the fruits of intelligent 
international emulation. 

This evening we learn of the death from wounds at 
the age of thirty-six of Charles Midler, co-author of 
those brilliant parodies called "A la Maniere de . . ." 
wherein he and M. Paul Rcboux passed in review 
the literature of all times and countries with as much 
wit as erudition. But, however dazzling the ability of 
these skits, they loft in the reader some of that dissatis- 
faction and scepticism that had given them birth. The 
author's sense of the ridiculous was as unsparing with 
the great as with the small. In fact the bigger the 



genius the bigger his mannerisms appeared through the 
magnifying glass of Midler's and Reboux's satire. There 
are others, besides his readers, who will regret poor 
Charles Midler; those who had received the consecra- 
tion of his satire and those who were expecting it. 

October tt. — In England, where the papers are, it 
appears, bristling with news (in how far genuine or 
really interesting I cannot say, as I see few) no idea can 
be formed of the economy of information dispensed here. 
The provinces have to be satisfied with next to nothing. 
We who are spoilt have to-day, for instance, to do with 
the following official bulletin and such commentaries and 
speculations as the ingeniousness of journalists can em- 
broider upon it. " The general situation is stationary. 
AT OUR RIGHT WING, action continues. IN AR- 
GONNE and on the heights of the Meuse, we have 
repulsed both night and day attacks." Plus half a dozen 
lines about the Russian victories. The Comtc de Mun 
writes in this morning's " Echo " that this parsimonious- 
ncss drives him to scour the English papers for informa- 
tion about the war's progress. Added to this fast in 
news a new rule forbids the publication of the names 
of all wounded. So much severity seems exaggerated 
caution. This evening I was given in exchange for a 
bank-note, the first gold I have seen for two months. 
In thi3 morning's "Echo" -VI. de Mun's daily leader 
commenting on the endless battle and the penury of news 
contained the following passagci : "To-night, after 
having written these lines, I will go to bed with hope 
in my heart. I hope, at the time they will be read, to 
awaken in enthusiasm." Perhaps this good Frenchman 
— excellent Christian, firm believer in his Catholic faith 
and intelligent propagator of its teachings — awakened 
to something even better than he hoped for, for at the 
hour he expected to hear at last of a great and definite 
victory, he was dead. Aged seventy-three be died of 
overstrain after writing a daily article for two months 
in the midst of the most tensely felt emotion and sup 
pressed anxiety ; an article which was each day an impas- 
sioned and dignified call to patriotism, confidence, calm 
and patience, aud the well-informed commentary of an 
ex-soldier. He wrote more than sixty articles in this 
hight-strnng note, without once recurring to cant. If 
the Comte dc Mun, Academician, politician, orator, 
author, died too soon to witness the final victory, he 
lived long enough to see the wisdom of his propaganda 
in favour of the three years' service and attention to the 
country's defences in opposition to the tendencies of the 
Radical and Socialist parties. 

October 7. — This morning we received the first card 
from a soldier since the beginning of the war. It is from 
Dr. dc N. — The weather continues very fine and propi- 
tious for fighting! — This noon a "Taube" the French 
pronounce " Tobe ') again flew over Paris. We heard 
the cannon from the Eiffel Tower announcing its pre- 
sence, but were unable to distinguish the German from 
its pursuers all flying at a great height above us. This 
evening came a second soldier's letter (from G.C.C., 
the poet. — Here is a story from the 'front : The two 
almoners of a certain corps are, the one a Roman Catho- 
lic missionary the other a rabbi. They arc great friends 
and do much good. One evening, having stayed long on 
a battlefield looking after wounded, they fouud it im- 
possible to return to their quarters, so they put up in 
a poor little farm where was but one wretched bed. So 
they lay down on it together in their clothes. Said the 
priest to the rabbi : " If a photographer happened to be 
here he could make a picture of the Old and New Testa- 
ments as bed-fellows." 

October 8. How charming is Paris without motor- 
buses! Certain streets at certain hours — at noon par 
ticularly, for war or no war Paris lunches and dines at 
its usual absolutely untransferable hours — are perfectly 
silent, the prospects clear, progress unimpeded. This 
peaceful condition makes one dread for the future 
bringing back the old noise, rattle and confusion. 
Mmc. V. has been telling me about the wounded she 
is nursing. To-day she had to sit a full hour holding 
with her two hands a wound which had reopened and 



408 



THE EGOIST 



November 2, 1914 



caused hemorrhage. Most of the men are brought in 
in so weak a state that they have to be operated upon 
without chloroform. The hands of men now arriving 
are unrecognisable as hands, so thickly crusted with 
earth are they ; and not the most expert hospital wash- 
ing can remove this coating, only a change of skin can 
do it. We moved into town to-day. 

OirrouEii 13.— Advertisement in this morning's paper: 
" R. . . L. . ., brigadier 8th Hussars, is notified 
that he is the father of a little girl born at St. B. . . 
on the 8th October, Mother and child well." I have 
allowed several days to pass without keeping my journal, 
which is a mistake as it is difficult to resume the thread. 
However, nothing very interesting occurred to us until 
yesterday when we went to see a friend at his temporary 
quarters near Saint Cyr, the French military school. 
The train thither was extremely crowded and progress 
slow. Some English soldiers got into the station at 
Versailles. They attracted curiosity as usual, but not so 
much as their petticoated colleagues. A little group of 
these stood on the platform waiting for orders, or 
squatted on their traps, in the midst of silently wonder- 
ing French soldiers. The freshness of the English a.nd 
Scots men's skins contrasted singularly with the paler 
complexions of the French. On alighting at . . . we 
had occasion to exchange a few words with the English 
soldiers, to whom people on the platform were bringing 
coffee and bread, and learnt that they were convalescents 
who had been in hospital atVersailles and were now off 
to Saint Nax.aire. For some little attention to them they 
said to me, '"'Thank you, lady," and this term of courtesy 
sounded strange on French soil. It also struck H. S. 0. 
who had never heard it away from London. — Here was 
Dr. ... in his new military uniform. The village 
was quartering some three thousand men and officers. 
We had had to bring our luncheon, as food is not provided 
to civilians. We ate it in the typical yard of a French 
inn. Dr. . . .'s regiment had only just arrived and 
was leaving again in a few days. It had not been 
under fire, but had once narrowly escaped falling into 
the hands of the Germans. Dr. . . . looked thinner 
and somewhat weary. In fact I notice that each one's 
early cheerfulness has been replaced not by lack of con- 
fidence, by any means, but by a certain strain and 
anxiety. We have all aged, but especially those who 
have come in direct contact with the hardest effects of 
the. war. While chatting with Dr. ... we were con- 
stantly interrupted by his orderly or infirmary assistant 
bringing messages. One of these struck us by the quiet 
precision of his speech, his interesting face. He is, in 
peace-time, a monk and renowned as a preacher. Monks 
and priests make the best of soldiers. As we were talk- 
ing who should we see but another friend, the writer, 
E.M., whom we were at some pains to recognise owing to 
his change of costume and that modification of physiog- 
nomy to which I have already referred. Yet it was not 
three months ago that we were all four gathered round 
the piano at the . . . while N. enchanted us with 
her rendering of Bach and Debussy. E.M., who is in the 
i;rnir (engineers), has been at this village ever since he 
was mobilised six weeks ago, spending long days of end- 
less monotony. — Dr. . . . took us round his village to 
show us his quarters, first the villa in which he lodges, 
then the plain, elementarily fitted room which serves 
him for his consultations and as laboratory. In the yard 
some Territorials (that is men aged between thirty-five 
and forty-eight) were unloading bread, round cakes as 
heavy as stones, long loaves like logs, -which they were 
piling up in a shed. From . . . we walked to Saint 
Cyr along one of those fine military roads which are 
France's monopoly, and at the station was the usual 
attendance of ladies distributing beverages, tobacco and 
flowers to the soldiers in the trains. In our compartment 
there were three soldiers, two of them belonging to the 
chasseur* alpins corps who did fine work in the East, hard- 
drilled, robust little mountaineers from the South, 
nimble and tireless like goats, surefooted and stubborn 
like mule6. Their outfit is much more sensible than that 
of the majority of French troops who find their red 
trousers and glittering galoons and buttons distinctly 



too favourable to the enemy's aim. The GkasBwn alpim 
are dressed in dark blue from head to foot like sailors, 
a tam-o'-shanter bearing a minute symbol, a tunic above 
the jersey, knickerbockers, puttees and a cape rolled 
like a sausage into a ring like a life-belt when not worn. 
These men are fresh-complexioned, they sound their i 's 
violently, but speak more correctly than the Northerners, 
and are hardened by weeks spent in the mountain snows. 
They fought brilliantly in the earlier contests of the war 
and have left great numbers behind them. Our three 
travelling companions were returning from a term in 
hospital in Normandy to join their headquarters, the 
two alpins at Montpellicr, their birthplace, the third at 
Carcassonne. The last had never been so far South, 
being a townsman from the Eastern provinces ; the other 
two had never been so far North, and when we reached 
Versailles its palace majestic in its golden, autumn 
frame — they asked where and what that place was. How 
they had travelled ! At least these long hours spent in 
endless trains were so many hours spent away from 
gun-fire. All they would see of Paris was what they 
could during the change of stations which would be 
chiefly underground. They had no time to waste. The 
Northerner, a delicately constituted young man, had 
brought an ugly little cough back from the front where 
he had been wounded, but it did not seem to occur to 
him that it might spare him another opportunity for 
being ''done with" altogether as he said smiling and 
resignedly. And one of the highlanders added: "And 
all that, will be nothing if we get the victory," a remark 
which, when you read it in the papers, seems to emanate 
direct from the journalist's imagination, but which is 
good to hear from the soldier himself. I heard it. 

Those good people, the L.'s, of Reims, have at last 
written. The letter did not come by post, but was 
brought by hand by some traveller bound for the capital. 
They say they have had to put up German officers and 
soldiers who ate and drank all they could find, but neither 
looted nor destroyed the slightest thing. (This was the 
privilege of all who stayed quietly at home; unoccupied 
houses were subjected to pillage.) They have had very 
hard times, remaining for days without bread, and at 
other times having nothing but a soup made of bread, 
water and salt, and again having (bitterest of plights!) 
to accept la soupe des allemands. Now their house is 
occupied by French officers and their daily fare is as- 
sured; communication with the town being still impos- 
sible they depend upon the military for their supplies. 

Octobee 15. — Alec Carter, the French naturalised 
jockey, of English parentage, young, good-looking, well 
educated and extremely popular in sporting circles, fol- 
lows Jean Bouin, the world's champion pedestrian 
(France's only world champion) on the wars death-roll. 

A few days ago I bought some brown bread at a 
baker's. When I asked for some to-day 1 was told the 
police had seized what had been found and forbidden 
the baking of any more under penalty. Why may wheat- 
meal be used and not rye? Why may buns be sold and 
not croissants? Why cakes and not Vienna crust? At 
first we thought the prohibition of fancy bread a good 
idea, it brought the war home to all. But when it is 
extended to plain rye bread, the use of which may relieve 
the exceptional demands made on wheat, then it seems 
quite absurd. As a rule the French despise rye and 
contemptuously pity the German for having to eat black 
bread, so now its assimilation with "fancies" or 
" luxuries " is at least surprising. Otherwise provisions 
continue normally except sugar and eggs which have 
risen in price as has also coal. Rock salt is again on the 
market, but such a refinement as table-salt must still be 
foregone. Grapes are to be had in quantities, but cer- 
tain dry wares, like bottles and paper have become 
scarce and among clothing woollen materials, notably 
men's socks and underclothing. Much work that used 
to be undertaken by men such as tram conducting and 
ticket punching on the underground line, is now in the 
hands of women, these being selected from among the 
wives of mobilised employes. They are generally yoimg, 
nice-looking, neat women and they fill their offices to 




November 2, 1914 



THE EGOIST 



409 



perfection. Their exceptional position commands respect 
and the disputes common on French traffic between pas- 
sengers and officials do not occur under feminine rule. 

Muriel Ciolkowska. 
(To be continued.) 

Erratum.— On page 388 of the last issue in the article 
on Odilon Redon (first column) " in our national view of 
life" should have read "in our rational view of life." — 
M.C. 

THE SONGS OF MALDOROR. 

By Tttk Comte df. Lautreamont. 

Part I. — (continued). 

A T my last hour (I write this on uiy death-bed) I shall 
-£»- not be seen surrounded by priests. I shall die 
cradled by the waves of a tempestuous sea, or 
standing on a mountain . . . my eyes will not be 
turned to heaven: I know that my annihilation will be 
complete. Moreover, I shall not have the grace of hope. 
Who opens the door of my death-chamber 1 I had said 
that, no one should come in. Whoever you are depart ; 
but if you think you will see signs of pain or of fear on 
my hyena-like face (L use this comparison though the 
hyena is more beautiful than I and more agreeable to 
look at), be undeceived: let him approach. We are in 
a winter's night, when on every side the elements are 
in confusion, when man is afraid and when the young 
man meditates some crime on one of his friends if it 
happens to be in my youth. Let the winds whose plain- 
tive murmurings sadden humanity since the winds, 
since humanity exist some moments before my 
last agony — let the winds bear me on the bones 
of his wings across the world, impatient for my 
death. Secretly I shall still enjoy numerous examples 
of human malice (a brother without being seen likes to 
see the acts of his brothers). The eagle, the raven, the 
imperishable pelican. the wild duck, the wandering 
crane trembling with cold, will see me pass in the glow 
of the stars, a horrible and contented spectre. They 
will not know what it means. On the earth, the viper, 
the. large eye, of the toad, the tiger, the elephant ; in the 
sea, the whale, the shark, the hammer-fish, the shape- 
less skate, the tooth of the polar seal, will ask them- 
selves what is this derogation to the laws of nature. 
Man, trembling, will hold his forehead to the dust in 
the midst of his outcries. "Yes, I surpass you all by 
my innate cruelty, a cruelty which it has not depended 
upon me to efface. Is it for this motive that you show 
yourself thus prostrated before me 1 Or is it that you 
see me, a new phenomenon, traverse bleeding space like 
a terrifying comet 1 ? (A rain of blood pours from my 
huge body like the dark cloud which the storm drives 
before it). Fear nothing, children, I will not curse you. 
The evil you have done me is too great, too great the 
evil I have done you that it should be voluntary. You 
have walked in your path, I have walked in mine; both 
similar, both perverse. Of necessity we had to meet each 
other, with this similitude of character; the shock which 
resulted has been fatal to us both." Then, men will lift 
up their heads little by little and take courage to see 
who is speaking in this manner, and will stretch out 
their necks like snails. Suddenly, their faces burning, 
discomposed, showing the most terrible passions, they 
will grin like frightened wolves. At the same time they 
will stand up like immense steel springs. What curses ! 
What bowlings of the voice ! They have recognised men. 
The animals of the earth unite themselves with men 
and make their bizarre clamours heard. No more re- 
ciprocal hate; the two hatreds arc turned against the 
common enemy me ; I fear their treachery ! Yes, 
let me disappear from their eyes little by little, com- 
pletely satisfied, a witness once more of the consequences 
of passions ... I thank you, O rhinopholus, for having 
awakened me with the movement of your wings — 
you whose nose is surmounted by a crest in the shape 
of a horse-shoe : I now perceive that it was unhappily 
only a slight illness, and with disgust I feel myself 



returning to life. Some say that you came to me to suck 
the little blood which is left in my body: why is this 
hypothesis not the reality ! 

* * * # 

A family surrounds a lamp plated on a table: 

"My son, give me the scissors which are on that 
chair." 

"They are not there, mother." 

" Go and get them in the next room then. Do yon 
remember the time, my sweet lord, when we prayed to 
have a child in whom wc should be born again and who 
would be the prop of our old age?" 

"I remember, and God has been good to us. We need 
not complain of our lot on this earth. Every day Provi- 
dence blesses us with new benefits. Our Edward has all 
his mother's graces." 

"And all the good qualities of his father." 

"Here are the scissors, mother; I have found them." 

He goes on with his work . . . but, somene has come 
to the door, and contemplates for several moments the 
picture which is offered to his eyes: 

"What does this sight mean? There are many people 
who are less happy than these. What reason have they 
for loving existence? Depart, Maldoror from this 
peaceable hearth ; your place is not here." 

He is gone ! 

" I don't know what has happened ; but I feel the 
human faculties giving battle in my heart. My soul is 
unquiet, without knowing why ; the atmosphere is 
heavy." 

"Woman, I feel the same impressions as yourself; I 
tremble lest some misfortune should come to us. Let us 
have, confidence in God ; in Him is the supreme hope." 

"Mother, T can scarcely breathe; my head hurts." 

" You too. mv son ! I will cool your head with vinegar." 

"No. mother ..." 

See, he rests his body on the back of the chair, tired 
out. 

" Something is turning round inside me — some- 
thing which 1 cannot explain. The slightest thing 
troubles me." 

"How pale you are: The end of this vigil will not 
come before some terrible event has plunged us all three 
in the lake of despair." 

I hear from afar long cries of the most poignant grief. 

"My son!" 

"Ah. mother! ... I am afraid." 

" Tell me quickiy — are you in painV " 

" No, mother . . . ah, that is not true." 

The father caimot recover from his astonishment: 

"These are the cries which are sometimes heard in the 
silence of starless nights. Although we hear these cries 
the sufferer is not near us; for these screams can be 
heard three miles away, borne by the winds from one 
city to another. I have often heard people speak of 
Ibis phenomenon ; but I have never heard them myself. 
Woman, you speak to me of misfortune ; if a more real 
misfortune existed in the long spiral of time, it is the 
misfortune of him who now troubles the sleep of his 
fellows ..." 

T hear from afar long cries of the most poignant grief. 

" May it please heaven that his birth be not a calamity 
for his country, which has cast him out of her bosom. 
Some say that, he is overwhelmed by a kind of original 
madness from his childhood. Others think that he is 
of an extreme and instinctive cruelty of which he is 
ashamed himself, and that this sorrow has killed his 
parents. There are others who say that he was blasted by 
a cognomen in his youth; that he has remained incon- 
solable for the rest of his existence because his wounded 
dignity saw in this a flagrant proof of the malice of man- 
kind, which showed itself in his first years and afterwards 
increased. This cognomen was The Vampirel . . ." 

I hear from afar long cries of the most poignant grief. 

"They add that, by night and by day, without respite 
or repose horrible nightmares make him bleed at the 
mouth and ears ; and that spectres sit on the 
rail of his bed and throw in his face -urged 
in spite of themselves by an unknown force, 
sometimes with a gentle voice sometimes in a voice 



no 



THE EGOIST 



November 2, 19 14 



like the roars of battle they hurl in his face 
with an implacable persistence this biting, hideous cog- 
nomen which will only perish with the universe. Some 
have affirmed that he was reduced to this state by love : 
or that these cries are caused by his repentance for 
some crime buried in the night of his mysterious past. 
But the greatest number think that he is tormented by 
an i mm. -asm-able pride, like Satan of old, and that he 
«lc ires to be the equal of God . . . ." 
T hear from afar long cries of the most poignant grief. 
(Translated by Richard kixsmmm). 
(7'n lir. continued.) 

Translator'* Not*. — This amazing work i-. in some ways, one 
nl' the niosl marvellous achievements in modern literature. The 
author was a Frenchman from Montevideo. His name was 
[sidore Dncasse, but he assumed the hkm de phime of Conite de 
Lautreamont. The b iok was written when the author was 
seventeen years old, in I8(i7. Ducasse died of fever at the age 
nf twenty. Had be lived, he might have been ''One of the 
glories of French literature," As it is, the work remaining is 
extr ly unequal, 

Lautreamonl was not marl, in spite of all opinions to the 
contrary. This has been proved by M. L. Genonceaux, in his 
preface to the "Chants de Maldoror." Neither did he suffer 
from any form of sexual aberration. He was simply an auda- 
cious genius who dared to think what no one had thought before 
ami wlio dressed his thoughts in such supreme irony that he 
really appears mad to the bourgeois intelligence of the modern 
world. 



WAR POETRY. 

" \\T !'• have called attention from time to time to the 
T! immense interest in poetry . . . which has 
sprung up during the past two or three years. 
Suddenly . . . the call to the poet has come, with the 
noblest of all themes to inspire him. Certainly ... he 
has not failed the call. Poetry, or at any rate verse, has 
poured forth." . . . 

Thus far the oracle of the " Times Literary Supple- 
ment. " I have before me. as I write, one of these out- 
pourings. It is called "Poems of the Great War" 
(Ohatto and Windus, Is. net.). On the brow u stained 
cover a woman is nursing a seemingly inanimate baby 
in a room upholstered, apparently, with flags of the 
nations. A scrubby youngster is drawing a sword 
several sizes too large for him. Touching picture ! Turn 
to the contents, only to find ourselves disarmed before 
the title page. Opposite it stands printed — 

DUTY. 

Give gladly, you rich — 'tis no more than you owe— 
For the weal of your country, your wealth's overflow ! 
Even I tliat am poor am performing my part; 
I am giving my brain, T am giving my heart. 

William Watson. 

What use England has for poor brains and hearts is 
not stated. Poets masquerading as beggarmen — the 
"weal " of England expressed in terms of the dividends 
of her subjects, (naturalised or otherwise)— these be 
stirring limes, my masters! 

Let us advance to the next redoubt. Robert Bridges. 
Poet Laureate of England sets the tone. Doric or Mixo- 
Lydian. Mr. Bridges will go down to posterity. He has 
already written such lines as " Uncanopied sleep is flying 
from tree to tree," or "Dreamy butterflies nnpilotcd in 
the sun." or "The Spring Goddess cowers in faint attire, 
of frightened fire." Like the "Observer" reviewer, 1 
am ashamed to have missed the beauty of these. 
Beauties of a common sort are in " Wake up, Knglaml ! " 

Thou careless, awake! 

Thou peacemaker, fight ! 
Stand, England, for Honour, 

And God guard the Right ! 



The foe is upon thee 
And grave is the day. 



The Monarch Ambition 
Hath harnessed his slaves; 

But the folk of the Ocean 
Are free as the waves. 

Up, careless, awake! 

Ye peacemakers, fight! 
England stands for honour : 
(And so say all of us) 

God defend the Right! 

Parliament ought surely to vote an increase of sack to 
the Laureate's doubtless exiguous salary. Mr. Bridges 
has made his niche in English literature secure; he 
stands beside Easden and Pye. Unless indeed it turns 
out that these verses are not really by Mr. Bridges but 
arc of the Kaiser's own manufacture, and were written 
to discredit, demoralise, and utterly metagrabolise poor 
England. Let it be looked into. 

Curiously enough, the next "poem" in this peerless 
assembly, by Henry Newbolt, expresses precisely the 
same sentiments: 

"England! where the sacred flame," etc., etc., etc. 

Watch beside thine Arms to-night, 
Pray that God defend the Right. 
The mystery deepens. Which was the first to think of 
that great, immensely original line? Or have the poets 
taken to spying on each other? Perish the thought! 

The rest of the volume is a little disconcerting. We 
are shocked by such cannonading rhymes and sentiments 
as — 

Let him (Wilhelm!) learn this, that the due grief 

Of his owji vice he cannot ban 
By outrage of a highway thief; 
Let him remember the Corse-sick-can — 
and we are only pacified when we learn that Maurice 
Hewlett is their author. Until I saw this name, T 
veritably believed that the Duke of Wellington had come 
to life again and taken up the pen in his country's 
defence. 

Next, Laurence Binyon rhymes "desire on" with 
"iron" and speaks of England — toujours Angleterre. ! — 
as being "In the hour of peril purified." This is a 
difficult line to enunciate properly. The first time I 
tried it I could only say, "In the hour of puerile peri- 
fied." Alfred Noyes, whom I thought of with half- 
sympathy as one holding down the arduous job of a 
Princeton professorship and Post-Laureate to America, 
has returned to the Motherland with "felon hands" and 
"scutcheons rent from sky to outraged sky! " 

I wish I could quote in full the next poem, by R. E. 
Vemede, whom the "Times," inter alia, seem to be 
backing for the next Laureateship stakes. Thus " Eng- 
land to the Sea" : 

Mc whom thou suckled'st on thy milk of foam — 
Have I not reared for thee time and again, 
And bid go forth to share thy fierce embraces, 
Sea-ducks, sea-wolves, sea-rovers, and sea-men? 
Polygamy was bad enough. Here is zoological pro- 
miscuity openly advocated. Shades of Prince Albert (of 
Schleswig-Holstein-Gottorp) and Alfred, Lord Tenny- 
son ! 
The next bard seizes the fantaiiriste lyre and exclaims : 
We've shut the gates by Dover Straits, 
And North, where the tides rim free, 
Cheek by jowl, our watch-dogs prowl, 
Grey hulks in a greyer sea! 
Bulldogs on the ocean ! Help, help, hooray ! 
Chesterton profits by his bulk to disguise himself as 
The Wife of Flanders" (Rubens might grow green 
with envy!) and to exclaim to an Uhlan : 

The great green land has trampled on her, 
The treason and terror of the night we met. 
It is a relief to turn from this tc the stern Miltonic 

i ing of : 

And now while the dark vast earth shakes and rocks 
In this wild dreamlike snare of mortal shocks, 

but not of laughter, let us hope. 



November 2, 1914 



THE EGOIST 



411 



More modern in its sentiment is this ineffable stanza : 
There's a man who fights for England, and he'll keep 

her still atop, 
He will guard her from dishonour in the markets (of 

Germany please) and the shop, 
He will save her homes from terror on the fields of — 

"Daily Mail," 
He's the man who sticks to business, and who knows 
how oft to fail. 
I am afraid I have not quoted this correctly. I am 
myself tempted to match, with my gentle skill, these 
lines : 

There's a man who is ' : a howler in the prairies of 

the west," 
Booth and Christ he set together, Rothschild's Cross 

is on his breast ; 
And his name is 'Arold Begbie. But they'll say 

when he is dead : 
"When the Muse showed him her ankles, still he 
always kept his head." 
After such incomparable rhymes, one is not at all 
surprised to find "France's hands taking hold of the 
battlements of Hell," as Cecil Chesterton has it, in the 
next morceau from this charming collection. 

I cannot, quote more from this little volume. Such 
samples as I have given must, suffice. One thing more 
remains to say. Let everyone buy this book. It only 
costs a shilling, and that shilling goes to the National 
Relief Fund. Those who are incapacitated by its 
reading will doubtless obtain their share of this fund 
later on. Those who are not, can do still another and a 
greater service to England by posting their copies to 
"The Kaiser, Potsdam, for Free Distribution to the 
German Army." If any such copies reach their destina- 
tion, we may all sleep secure in our beds, as Lord 
Rosebery long ago exhorted us to do. The German 
Army will explode with laughter, and everyone will see 
that "poetry, or at any rate verse," is of some use 
after all. 

John Gould Fletcher. 

THE ORANGE SYMPHONY. 

By John Gould Fletcher. 

I. 

Now that all the world is filled 

With armies clamouring : 

Now that men no longer live and die, one by one, 

Hut in vague indeterminate multitudes : 

Now that the, trees are coppery towers, 
Now that the clouds loom southward, 
Now that the glossy creeper 
Spatters the walls like spilt wine : 

I will go out alone, 
To catch strong joy of solitude 
Where the treelines, in gold and scarlet, 
Swing strong grape-cables up the smouldering face of 
the hill. 

II. 

Guns crashing, 

Thudding, 

Ululating, 

Tumultiuus. 

Guns yelping over the cracked earth, 

Where dry bugles blare. 

Here in this hollow 

It is very quiet, 

Only the wind's hissing laughter 

In the place of tombs. 

One by one these gaunt scarred faces 
Lift up blurred wrinkled inscriptions 
Silently beseeching me to stop and ponder. 
What does it matter if I do not stop to read them? 
No one at all has gone this way that I have chosen 
before. 



A leaf drops slowly in silence: 

It is a long time twisting and hovering on its way to the 
earth. 

Guns booming, 

Bellowing, 

Crashing, 

Desperate. 

Insistent outcry of savage guns. 

Rocking the gloomy hollow. 

I will run out like the wind, 

Snarling, with savage laughter; 

Like the wind that tosses the grey-black clouds, 

Against the shot-racked barrier of flaming trees. 

I will race between the grey guns, 
And the clouds, like shrapnel exploding, 
Flinging their hail through the tumuli, 
Bursting, will melt in cold spray. 

I am the wanderer of the world ; 

No one can hold me. 

Not the cannon assembled for battle, 

Nor the gloomy graves of the hollow, 

Nor the house where 1 long time slumbered, 

Nor the hilltop where roads are straggling. 

My feet must march to the wind. 

Like a leaf dropping slowly, 
An orange butterfly turning and twisting, 
I touch with moist passionate palms the leaden inscrip- 
tions 
Of my past. Then I turn to depart. 

III. 

The trees dance about the inn ; 

The wind thrusts them into flamelets. 

Now my thoughts gipsying, 

Go forth to strange walls and new fires. 

Mouths stained with brown-red berries, 

Bronzed cheeks sunken, unshaven, 

Ragged attire ; 

We swing our guitars at the hip 

As we tramp heedless, uncaring. 

In the inn the fire crackles; 

On the hearth the wine is simmering. 

Lift up the brown beaker one instant, 

Drink deeply — iling out the last coin — Let us go. 

On the plains there is drooping harvest, 

Rut no harvest can for long time hold us, 

We have seen the winds battled. 

Racing up the orange-flecked trench of the hills. 

IV. 

On the hill summit 

Where the gusty wind all night long has assailed me. 

Now I see stars vanishing 

Before the long cold clutching fingers of dawn. 

Stars, scintillant, fire-hued, metallic, 
Tupazc fruit of the deep blue garden: 
Southward you go, my constellations, 
And leave me with the white day, alone. 

Over the hilltop 
Swish with scurry of wings 
Millions of pale brown birds, 
Songless, pulsing southward. 

Birds who have filled the trees, 
And who fled long ago at my passing, 
Now you clatter in heedless tumult, 
Fanning with your hot w ings my face. 

Carry this word to the southward: 
Say that I have forgotten theiu that wait for me. 
All the loves and the hates need expect me no longer, 
In tiie autumn at last I am alone. 



m 



THE EGOIST 



November 2, 19l4 



.Suddenly 

The wind crashes through the tree-tops. 
Stripping away their orange-tiled domes; 
Stark blue skeletons, forbidding 
Gesticulate in my face. 
You whom I planted and lavished 
With all the wealth and beauty I had to bestow. 
Hurry away, vain harvest, 
The winds' scythes can reap you, 

Where yon lie on the earth, and to death's barns you 
can go. 

I'ii. yond the hilltop 

T have seen only the sky. 

The wind, naked, prodding up black-furred clouds, 

Cossacks of winter. 

Cry, wind, 

Shriek to the shivering southland, 
That I am going into winter, 
That I do not hope to return. 

Farewell, crowded stars, 

Farewell, birds, winds, clouds and tree-tops, 
I, weary of you all, 1 seek my destined joy in the north- 
land, 
Amid blue ice and the rose-purple night of the pole. 

V. 

Beyond the land there lies the sea: 
And on the sea with wings unfurled, 
Bloodily huge the sunset rests, 
Feathers nickering and claws curled, 
Watching to seize the ruined world. 

Rolling in a torrent, 

Brown leaves, my achievements, 

Rise up from dark-wooded valleys 

And scatter themselves on the sea; 

Brown birds, my wild dreams, 

Mingle their bodies together, 

Shrieking and clamouring as they pass, 

Black charred silhouettes 

Against the west, curtained in orange flame. 

Now the wind starts up 

And strikes the seething water: 

Hissing in uncoiled fury 

Each foam-curled wave darts forward 

To clash and batter 

The smouldering iron-rust cliff, 

Where the end of my road is lost. 

Rise up, black clouds ; 

Pounce upon the sunset: 

Tear it with your jagged teeth. 

Fling yourselves, seething winds, in circles 

Upon the blue-black water, 

Swirl, leaves, and dance 

Amid the chaos of breakers, 

Flicker, birds, an instant 

Against the tawny tiger throat of the sun 

Which is snarling in the west. 

Beat -down, O great winds, westward, 

Loose reins and gallop to seaward, 

Rush me too, to that ocean, 

In which I have found my goal. 

Lash me, lap me, rugged waves of blue-black water, 
Dash me, clutch me and do not let me rest one instant: 
All through the purple-blue night rock and soothe me, 
Till I awaken dreamingly at the faint rose breast of the 
dawn. 



ART AND DRAMA. 

IBSEN AND STRINDBERG AT WAR TIME. 



M 



R, JAMES HENDERSON, of Charing Cross Road, 
issuiug a pocket edition of "Plays Worth 



is 



Reading," by Ibsen and Strindberg, at the within- 
reachable price of sevenpence each. The first issues are 
Ibsen's "An Enemy of Society," " Rosmersholm," "The 



Lady from the Sea," "The Doll's House," "Ghosts," ' 
' The Pillars of Society," and Strindberg's " Miss 
Julie," "Comrades," "The Creditor," "The Stronger 
Woman," and "Motherly Love," " Paria and Simoon." 
Why are we bidden to consider these plays at war time'? 
Apparently because their authors were interested in 
conflict. But the conflict which specially interested 
Ibsen and Strindberg (the dismal psychologist) was the 
war of the sexes. This particular interest varies in their 
plays according as their vision varies. If Ibsen was for 
the civilised woman against civilised man, Strindberg 
was the reverse. Ibsen saw the fundamental truth 
underlying the relation of the sexes, and the colossal lie 
which centuries of blindness had superimposed upon it 
with so much force and so much skill. The truth was 
this : Woman is not separate from Man but a part of him. 
She is within him, just as Man is within Woman. Now 
any conspiracy by human beings to separate Man and 
Woman by setting up a different standard of conduct for 
each, and by conferring rulership on one or the other, is 
bad, and sex relations founded upon this basis of separa 
lion arc inconceivably false. Ibsen was .aware of the lie 
of this truth and successfully exposed it in "The Doll's 
House." I have spoken of Ibsen's interest in conflict. 
But it is noticeable that in handling his plot interest he 
invariably contrives to raise it above the level of conflict 
to unfolding. We can trace, this unfolding process in 
"The. Doll's House." We see the author's vision of the 
fundamental unity of the human soul, then the devitalis- 
ing process set up by the soul's separation into two sexes, 
the attempt of one sex to subjugate the other, the course 
of this duel for life in space and time, the sudden 
awakening of the oppressed half (Nora) to a conscious- 
ness of its lost position, the initiation into the truth of 
its nature and significance, the uplift towards liberation 
and the final promise of the recapture of its own. These 
are facts to be traced in " The Doll's House," and by his 
management of them Ibsen leads us into the very core 
of drama and dramatic expression. In fine, this play, 
like "Rosmersholm," begins at the physical climax and 
ends at the spiritual. Hence the significance given to 
suicide in "Rosmersholm" (in " Hedda Gabler" also) 
is not a physical but a spiritual one. Ibsen seems to say 
that the ignorance and folly of mankind has led to this 
dilemma. Cnder existing social conditions no two human 
souls can come together in complete harmony except 
through the death of the bodies which contain them. In 
fact, the spiritual-minded ought not to be born. But, 
being born, death opens up the fairest prospect of life to 
them. The spiritual unity of the sexes was the subject 
of a play by Miss Janette Steer, which I recently saw 
performed at the Court Theatre. T hope to return to it. 
* * * 

Ibsen then saw that the Ego has no sex. But mankind 
has given it, two sexes. So long as there are two sexes 
mankind will continue to believe that it is essential one 
of the two should be humiliated. Clearly the sexes must 
go. I think it was due to the unity of soul in him that 
Ibsen attained the said vision. 1 mean it was the Woman 
in Ibsen that experienced the fundamental truth and saw 
so clearly the evil of separation. I think fundamental 
truths are the qualities of that to which they belong. 
Wisdom does not dwell in the mind that is subject to 
unwisdom. And it was because Strindberg lacked this 
unity that he wrote so destructively about Woman. He 
had the Woman element in him, but something had 
poisoned it, and every impression he received through 
this side of him was poisonously expressed. He simply 
wrote what the poisoned woman wanted him to write. 
This accounts for his faithful portraits of devitalised, 
servile Woman (and not of a type as an immature mind 
might suppose). He represents her as hideous, ill-pro- 
portioned, crawling, a whining hypocrite, living on Man 
and undermining hhn. Take "The Creditor." Here we 
have Woman in all her blatant unloveliness. She has no 
ego of her own. She sucks out her second husband's 
and leaves him a wreck. Says he, it is " as though she 
were a part of my ego. a piece out of my inside, that 
stole away my will." His "very marrow " is " in her." 
He is accounting for his lost power of creation, health, 



Noveiii her 2, 1914 



THE EGOIST 



413 






everything. In fact, says the first husband, " she has 
devoured your soul" . . . "as savages devour their 
enemies." He, too, has experienced the sweating 
capacity of the. creature and has no illusions left about 
her real nature. These plays of his, in spite of their 
big cargo of strong meat, are not dramatic. They are 
dissection, not soul-movement as in Ibsen's plays. 
Still, they will be read by the complete misogynist, 
who in the reading thereof will grow as young and 
lusty as an eagle. They will be distributed in tens 
of thousands by the Anti-Suffs. They will be compared 
with Ibsen's by students who are undecided whether 
women are angels (Ibsen) or men are gods (Strindberg). 
And they will be avoided by the Victorian young Miss 
with a silk shoe and a simper. 

Huntly Carter. 



PRELIMINARY ANNOUNCEMENT 
OF THE COLLEGE OF ARTS.* 

IT has been noted by certain authors that London is 
the capital of the world, and " Art is a matter of 
capitals." At present many American students who 
would have sought Vienna or Prague, or some con- 
tinental city are disturbed by war. To these The College 
of Arts offers a temporary refuge and a permanent 
centre. 

We draw the attention of new students to the fact that 
no course of study is complete 'without one or more years 
iu Loudon. Scholarly research is often but wasted time 
if it has not been first arranged and oriented in the 
British Museum. 

The London collections are if not unrivalled at least 
unsurpassed. The Louvre has the Venus and the Victory 
but the general collection of sculpture in the Museum 
here is, as a whole, the finer collection. The National 
Gallery is smaller than the Louvre but it contains no 
rubbish. 

Without, chauvinism we can very easily claim that 
study in London is at least as advantageous as study 
elsewhere, and that a year's study in London by no 
means prevents earlier or later study in other capitals. 

The American student coming abroad is usually pre- 
sented with two systems of study, firstly, that of 
"institutions" for the most part academic, sterile, pro- 
fessorial; secondly, instruction by private teachers often 
most excellent, often the reverse. 

The College of Arts offers contact with artists of 
established position, creative minds, men for the most 
pari who have already suffered in the cause of their art. 

Recognising the interaction of Ihe arts, the inter- 
stimulous, and inter-enlightenment, we have gathered 
the arts together, we recommend that each student shall 
undertake some second or auxiliary subject, though this 
is in all cases left to his own inclination. We recognire 
that certain genius runs deep and often in one groove 
only, and that some minds move in the language of one 
medium only. But this doe3 not hold true for the general 
student. For him and for many of the masters one art 
is the constant illuminator of another, a constant 
refreshment, 

The college prepares two sorts of instruction; one for 
those who intend a career in some single art, who desire 
practical and technical instruction, a second for those, 
who believe that learning is an adornment, a gracious 
and useless pleasure, that is to say for serious art 
students and for the better sort of dilettanti. 

The cost of instruction will very from £20 to £100, 
depending on how much the student wishes to do him- 
self and how much he wishes to have done for him. 
We recognise that the great majority of students now 
coming to Europe are musical students, the next most 
numerous class are painters and sculptors; we. neverthe- 
less, believe that there are various other studies which 
would be pursued if students knew where to go for 
instruction. 



* This interesting prospectus comes to hand. Its value is such 
that, we hasten to print it entire. 



We try not to duplicate courses given in formal insti- 
tutions like the University of London, or purely 
utilitarian courses like those of Berlitz. London is 
itself a larger university, and the best specialists are 
perhaps only approachable in chance conversation. We 
aim at an intellectual status no lower than that attained 
by the courts of the Italian Renaissance. 

Our organisation is not unlike that of a University 
graduate school, and is intended to supplement the 
graduate instruction in "arts." This instruction is 
offered to anyone who wants it, not merely to those 
holding philological degrees. 

A knowledge of morphology is not essential to the 
appreciation of literature, even the literature of a for- 
gotten age or decade. 

M. Arnold Dolmetsch's position in the world of music- 
is unique, and all music lovers are so well aware of ib. 
that one need not here pause to proclaim it. Painting 
and sculpture are taught by the most advanced and bril- 
liant men of our decade, but if any student desires in- 
struction in the earlier forms of the art, instruction in 
representative painting awaits him. The faculty as 
arranged to date, though it is still but a partial faculty, 
is perhaps our best prospectus. 

SCULPTURE. 
Atelier of Sculpture Gaudter-B.izeska 

PAINTING. 

Atelier of Painting Wiwdiiam Lewis 

Assistant, and Director of the Atelier, II. Sanders. 
Alelier of Design ... ... Ehwaiih Wadsworth 

Representational Painting (miniature) 

Private instruction Mathilde Huhn 

Portraiture, and the History of Occidental Painting 

Reginald Wilenski 
(Writer on the History of the Fine Arts to 
"The Athenwum ") 
Etching and Dry Point Wm. P. Robixs 

MUSIC. 

Ancient Music Arnold Dolmltsch 

Modern Instruments : 

Violin Senyei (arrangement pending) 

Cello Felix Salmond 

Assistant, Beatrice Eveline. 

Piano K. R. Ht.yman 

Assistant, Gladys Hamilton. 

Voice Robert db Bkouoe 

Diseuse Afc.ette Foeet 

Lecturer on modern Russian Composers ... Edwin Evans 

LETTERS. 

Comparative Poetry Ezra Pocnd, M.A. 

Author of "Persome," "Exultations." "The. 
Spirit of Romance " (a study of the medieval . 
poetry of latin Europe), " The Approach to 
Paris" (a series of papers dealing with Ihe 
contemporary poetry of France, "New 
Age"), etc., translator of Guido Oaval- 
canti's " Ballate " and of the " Canzoni of 
Arnaul Daniel"; Contributor to "The 
Quarterly Review." "The Fortnightly Re- 
view," etc., Sometime Fellow in Romanies 
of the University of Pennsylvania, now in 
charge of the late Ernest Fenollosas papers 
dealing with Chinese lyric poetry and the 
Japanese stage. 

Russian Novelists ... Ivan .Korshunk. (John Couknos) 
Translator of various tales by Gogol, 
Koroienko, Dostoyevsky, Gorky Turgenev, 
Chekov, Andreyev, Sologub, Remizov, etc. 
(World's Masterpiece series), Contributor to 
"The. Forum," " Lippincntt's," "The 
Mask," etc. 



-Ill- 



THE EGOIST 



Russian Contemporary Thought Zi.naiua Vangeeowa 
Published works: Seven volumes of essays in 
Russian. Contributor to " The Fortnightly 
Review," etc. 

Dramatic-Criticism Civil [nslee-Doebian 

Late dramatic critic of 'The New York 
Tribune," general European representative 
of the Oliver Morosco Company (Lo« AngeleB 
and New York). 

PHOTOGRAPHY. 
Studio Alvi.v Lanodon OOBtras 

(RAFTS. 
(in course of arrangement). 

•Silver and Ornament Labokatqk* Sam.hk'm 

Pottery 

Furniture, and Reproduction... 
Book-binding (Plain Letter Illuminating, Tool- 
work, Inlay, Restoration) ... Q. SoTcwrris 
Printing ('has. T. Jacobi (Man- 
aging Partner of the 
( 'hiswick Press). 

Engraving, Wood-cut 

Metalwork 

Enamel 

Jewels 

"The (rafts become the Fine Arts when men of 
sufficient culture maintain thein." 

THE DANCE. 
XVI. Century Dances Mas. Doimetsob 

Communications should be addressed to the Secre- 
tarial Offices, 5, Holland Place Chambers, Kensington, 
London, W.. to Vaughn Baron, Sec. 

As a supplement to the various courses in arts and 
crafts, we point out the value of individual research in, 
and study of, the various collections of the South 
Kensington, and British Museums. We will en- 
deavour to save the student's time by giving general 
direction for such work, and initiation in method, apart 
fiom the usual assistance offered by the regular Museum 
officials. 

In certain rare cases, the American college student, 
desiring more than his degree, will find it possible to 
spend his Junior or Sophomore year in London and 
return to his own Lhiivcrsity for graduation. Those 
desiring to do this should of course submit to us their 
plans of study, together with a clear statement of their 
requirements for graduation at the home college. Such 
students will have to possess rather more than average 
intelligence. 

If intending to take graduate work for higher degrees, 
I hey may, however, find that this form of recess will give 
them a distinct advantage over their colleagues, such 
as fully to compensate for the inconvenience and de- 
rangement of undergraduate studies. It is always open 
to them, to fill in routine courses by application to the 
University of London (that is to say, ordinary mathe- 
matics or classics) pursuing said courses in conjunction 
with their special work with the College of Arts. 

(En/I of Prospectus). 

Remarks. The college should come as a boon to 
various and numerous students who would otherwise be 
fugging about in continental pensions, meeting one 
single teacher who probably wishes them in the inferno, 
and dependent for the rest on fellow boarders and public 
amusements. 

Secondly, it would seem designed to form itseif into 
a centre of intelligent and intellectual activity, rather 
than a. cramming factory where certain data are pushed 
into the student regardless of hi6 abilities or pre- 
dilections. 

We note with interest that M. Dolmetsch's book on 
"The Interpretation of The Music of the XVH. and 
XVIII. centuries " is announced as about to appear. 



THE THEATRE. 

rililE theatre is the staging for emotion; has been. 
X must be. . . . 

Emotion invariably translates itself into action. 
immediate or deferred; 

Never in words. 

Words are a waste product of emotion and do not 
concern it. 

Thus the intellectual drama is not, drama at all. 

It is the "acting version" of a novel. 

This much for Shakespeare. 

The new school Strindberg.--Tchekhov. 

* * # 

A fool is not known .as such by his words. 

His actions are the clue to his madness. 

Similarly the hero, the villain. 

The secret springs which move them and which the 
dramatist considers himself bound to expose have but a 
literary value and do not concern us when shown upon 
the stage. 

The idea that they interest even is mistaken. 

A successful play however is a valuable property. 

There are also actors and actresses. 

A play of pure emotion would need a tithe of the 
present cast of a play, a hundredth of the expense in 
staging. ... 

Hence its impracticability. 

* * * 

The successful playwright. Shakespeare, Tchcklmv 
later, discovered that without action of some sort, no 
play "will go." That is, a play without some spec 
tacular interest. No two senses may be concentrated 
without one losing somewhat in intensity. A sonata 
cannot be criticised and heard intensely at the same 
moment. Nor the music of a ballet when the choreo- 
graphy is ovei-loaded. 

The only form of drama which evades these mistakes 
is that made by "Marionettes." That is, conven 
tionalised figures which do not draw attention to their 
idiosyncrasies; placed in a neutral environment which 
docs not detract from the evocation of a pure emotion. 

For hundreds of years this lias heen understood. 

It must not be lost sight of. 

THE EVOCATION OF RACE MEMORIES. 

Art no longer attempts to elevate. So rare indeed 
is it to meet one who believes in a utilitarian art that it 
was a profound shock for me to hear lately, " but I don't 
sec what use your poetry is." 

Not attempting to elevate, Art becomes entirely a 
factor for the suggestion of emotions ; thoughts. 

With the old artists, too often it was merely a hitting 
of the same nail after it had impinged .thus driving it 
into a groove where the vibrations were deadened 
instead of merely a first tap which would have caused 
the whole of the receptive material to vibrate (the 
liberation of a complex). 

It is conceivable that a smell of musk wafted through 
a theatre would affect an audience more poignantly, 
more profoundly, than anything they had before then 
experienced. For all plays are amenable to intellectual 
criticism of whatever kind. Hamlet need not affect a 
single member of the audience who does not wish it. 
This insidious smell of musk penetrates deeper into the 
mind through the senses, until the body is rapt into 
those vague splendid imaginings which are the flutterings 
of memories of man and the earth when they were young. 

Who knows why a leaf pittering along a starlit path 
Jills one with a sense of impending tragedy which sur- 
passes all the poignancy made by poets telling oT great 
loves? An empty stage, quite dark; the rustling of a few 

leaves I can conceive nothing which could affect me 

more poignantly, more profoundly. 

I want to take a theatre in London, using for the plays 
either human marionettes of the Dutch-doll type or naked 
humans, or to clothe them in a sort of cylindrical gar- 
ment. The plays will be the completion of a cycle dealing 
with the primitive emotions, of which Fear is one, these 
being I think the simplest for the evocation of race 



November 2, 191 !• 



THE EGOIST 



415 



memories. The Margaret Morris theatre in Chelsea 
might be procured fairly cheaply, and it is cosy and 
intimate. About £-20 would pay for two shows and I 
should be glad to hear from readers who are interested 
and how much they are prepared to contribute to such 
an end. 

FEAR, 

A large room. At back the wall is semi-transparent 
and dimly through this the opposite wall of the corridor 
may be seen. A figure passing down this corridor would 
appear shadowy and in silhouette. Everything in the 
room is very clear in the strong light of a hot summer 
afternoon. There is a door, back left corner. 
Pierrot and Columbine play chess. 
They play in silence for many seconds. 
Then steps are heard. They commence in the upper 
parts of the house, moving slowly clown a corridor, very 
deliberately descending the. stairs until they reach the 
door of the room. 

Nobody. 

The corridor remains empty. 

Pierrot goes to the door, which he opens casually, 
glances out and, seeing nothing, returns to the chess- 
men. Columbine has sat quietly watching the guine. 

Again steps are heard. 

Pierrot hears them while they are still in the upper 
parts of the house ; listening intently as they descend the 
stairs. He rushes to the door, fumbling at the handle. 
The steps fade away. 

Again he returns to the table. 

Columbine trembles when a pawn is put down. 

The steps recommence, slowly and deliberately. 

When they reach the dour Pierrot flings it open. 

Nothing ! 

Columbine stands trembling. 

Both wait behind the open door trembling. 

Again the steps are heard descending, but slyly and 
maliciously and lingering as though familiarly on the 
boards, till it reaches them'. 

Nothing. 

And they tremble. 

Wearily they return to the chess board. 

They hear suddenly two short steps and a lap at the 
door. 

Pierrot rushss to the door. 

Columbine has risen. Suddenly she starts as though 
touched — and again— and again. She begins weeping, 
but no sound is heard. 

The steps, deliberate and very clear, recommence in 
the upper corridor. 

Pierrot wearily returns to the chess. 

The steps are not heard. 

They recommence playing, often starting as the 
pieces touch the board. 

The steps are heard. 

Pierrot rushes from the room. 

His figure is silhouetted vaguely through the semi 
transparent wall as he rushes to and fro. 

Twilight is in the room. 

Columbine stands still. 

Suddenly she turns as though touched by someone — 
and again — and again. Unable to bear the strain, she 
rushes after Pierrot. 

Two pairs of feet arc heard running through the upper 
parts of the house. 

A door slams. 

Occasionally they pass each other behind the semi- 
transparent wall, but as though oblivious of each other, 
stopping and turning often, bewildered. . . . 

They are heard mounting stairs. 

The rushing of feet grows fainter, louder, fainter. 
Sometimes a third pair of feet seems to be echoing them, 
sometimes distinct, sometimes mere echo. 

It seems to be playing, softly and slyly and maliciously 
moving over the boards and after it, the feet of Pierrot 
and Columbine. 

In the corridor behind the semi-transparent wall, 
Pierrot and Columbine run wildly past each other, to and 
fro, to and fro. . . . 



Sometimes it seems there is another form, more 
tenuous still, moving with them, in and out, in and out, 
disappearing sometimes. 

They are heard moulding stairs. Two pairs of feet 
loudly and hurriedly, and after them, softly and slyly and 
maliciously, a third. 

Very suddenly, deep silence. 

Stage clicks into complete darkness and is empty half 
a minute. 

Curtain descends rustily. 

Joan RouKiii;. 



CORRESPONDENCE. 

NOTF. TO CoilRESPONDENTS.— While ,,, cite wffltMg to publish letters 
under nunis de plume, we make il a condition, of publication 
that the -name anil address of tack correspondent, should be 
gv.pplied to the Editor. — Ei>. 

* * * 

WAlt IS AX ILLUSION. 

To the Editor, The Egoist. 
Madam, 

I am glad of the opportunity, afforded by .Miss Florence 
Bradford's letter, to clear one or two fundamental points 
obscured by condensation. My argument may be put this way. 
War is an illusion. It ia an illusion of an illusion — namely 
material civilisation. This illusion operates upon the mind of 
man in .such a way as to cause it to manifest all the symptoms' 
of a malignant disease. Perhaps il is simpler to say the illusion 
itself is a disease. But let me consider the matter from a civi- 
lisation point of view. Formerly warfare had a biological causer 
or justification. Then il was a part of the process of physical 
natural selection. In tribal warfare, both the strong and the 
weak went to light, and the superior tribes, mentally and physic- 
ally, tended to eliminate the inferior tribes. This process con 
tinning during hundreds of years, doubtless promoted human 
[physical) evolution. Modern warfare has not this biological 
justification. From an evolutionary standpoint il is harmful — 
i.e., its biological (racial) influence is harmful. Educationally, 
il is said (especially by editors with the school teacher mind"), 
to have its value. It inculcates discipline and courage, and 
promotes physical development. But, unfortunately for the 
educationist, this has no racial influence, seeing that acquired 
characters arc not inheritable. Thus to he of service to man- 
kind warfare, must take place in each generation. And if 
warfare has no lasting educational value, it is also bad eugenically 
(to use a much derided term). In some, cases it tends to elimi- 
nate only the most fit physically ; in others, the most fit mentally 
and physically. In countries where soldiering is voluntary, as 
with England, it is said to tend to eliminate the most brave, 
and this is a loss, for courage is a valuable mental asset. But 
the statement must be taken with caution, at least till we know 
what is meant by present-day courage, and the approaches to 
the origin of the fighting instinct in the modern recruit have 
been considered. Many men are caught by vivid military uni 
forms ostentatiously displayed. Others enlist for ecoiioiiih- 
reasons. And we gather from the avalanche of " Letters from 
the Front" that courage is being largely confused with indif- 
ference or neutrality. Apparently the 'effect of being continually 
under fire is to deprive the mind of will-power, and to render 
it utterly unconscious of hardship, danger, or whatever is trans- 
piring. In fact, we have the clearest evidence that the present 
war. instead of improving the moral qualities of the combatants, 
i.< absolutely dehumanising the millions engaged in it. We 
cannot take up the "Times" without reading of something like 
the following: "Two armoured cars full of English surprised 
three Uhlans. _ Two of the Uhlans were soon accounted for, 
and a nice point arose for settlement between two of our men 
who were stalking the second of litem. Each of the English 
claimed that, this German was 'his man,' and the matter was 
only amicably resolved by both firing together ami sharing the 
bag." Note the sporting phraseology. Nothing more is needed 
lo enable us to realise the full glut of this bloody business. 
And it adds plausibility to the anthropological statement that 
man of all animals is the fiercest and most brutal fighter. No 
other species fight among themselves as memhers of the human 
species do. Among animals below turn the intra-specien fighting 
is practically limited to fighting between polygamous males for 
the female — victory falling to the most powerful — and to females 
fighting to protect their young. Tn other words, the fighting 
mstincl has a sexual origin. Anthropologists notice that the 
brutality and cruelty associated with fighting is confined to 
human brings. There is no evidence tn show that animals are 
cruel. The carnivorous animals fight to kill. They do not stop 
to give murder the brutal air of a pigeon-shooting match, as 
apparently some of our low-browed loafers at the front are 
doing. To sum up. Where soldiering is voluntary, warfare 
tends to eliminate the most fit. physically: but where it is com 
pulsory, as with France and Germany, it tends to eliminate the 
most fit, mentally and physically. In both cases it kills off packs 
of picked hirelings and military "sportsmen" out for "bags." 
T now come to Miss Bradford's question* What becomes of 
the most fit mentally who by reason of their physical unfitness 



416 



THE EGOIST 



November 2, 1014 



are untouched by modern warfare? Do they tend to increase? 
And if so, would lasting warfare have the* desirable effect of 
promoting human evolution on a higher plane than hitherto? 
In order to reply, let me first restate these points. (1) Modern 
warfare tends to eliminate the most fit physically, (ti) leaving 
(a) weaklings, (b) wasters, («•) mentally fit* What do I mean 
by mentally fit? By the most fit mentally I mean those indi- 
viduals in whom the highest inheritable mental characters are 
the most strongly developed. Such individuals are drawn 
together by a form of mental attractiveness that principally 
uperates to subjugate animal passion and sexual relations. Tin's 
means (3) the most fit mentally do not tend to carry on the 
nice. |l) But weaklings and wa-ter- tend to multiply very 
rapidly. My own medical experience has taught me this. 
(5) Therefore, modern warfare tends to result in a surplus 
population of these classes. (6) Its effect in this direction is 
largely aided by modern scientific discovery and the modern 
conspiracy to thwart Natural Selection in its effort to eliminate 
undesirables. Thus (7) the natural channels for reducing the 
surplus population are interfered with as follows : («) War, 
selection of the most fit, physically; (/>) Famine, largely neu- 
tralised by improved facilities of transit ; (c) Pestilence, (.-necked 
by sanitation (hygiene) ; (</) the amazing benevolent interest 
for keeping putrescent human beings alive. (8) The artificial 
channel seen in a declining birth-rate is rendered inoperative 
through being used by the wrong class. 

My Conclusion is that modern warfare does not promote human 
evolution. It imparts no lasting material benefits, and certainly 
confers no spiritual ones upon members of the human race. It 
is a malignant disease, and all who support it, of course, are 
a part of the disease. 

Histlt Carter. 

SCENK >1: ENTER J. C. 

Tu the Editor, The Egoist. 

Madam, 

When a " walking-on " gputleman in journalism enters 
upon the pitiless path of logic, the quickest way to get rid of 
him is to strangle him with his own stupidity. Ihe young 
Russian gentleman, Mr. John Cournos, is out to discredit the 
accuracy of my statements concerning Wagner and Mr. Gordon 
Craig. This is how he does it. 

First paragraph. (1) To prove temperamental vveakuess and 
unsound judgment he makes use of the dishonest trick of merely 
exhibiting a letter whose very nature demands that it should 
be read in full. ('2) Wilfully changes the sense of the letter 
from an explanation to an "apology." The letter does not 
contain one word of apology. There is no need of it. What 
ever I said in my book at the time it was written was necessary 
to be said. But some statements were no longer necessary when 
the book was published two years later. Mr. Craig had chauged 
his attitude, and given evidence of the chauge. I took full 
advantage of the new matter, and included it in my book, at 
the same time modifying my tone here and there. Finding, 
however, that the publisher had omitted some of the revisions, 
1 wrote to Mr. Craig and pointed this out, giving him, at the 
same time, the fact and history of the present form of the book. 
I did not wish it to be thought that 1 take a malign pleasure 
in routing opponents. (3) Tears a sentence out of the context 
to strengthen a charge of weakness. The mood T experienced 
at the time of writing my book did not affect my judgment or 
accuracy. Second and fourth paragraphs. Quotes me rightly 
as saying that Wagner bequeathed the " mystic-form of drama," 
in order to misrepresent me as implying that " Wagner handed 
down mysticism," or the thing behind the form, and that the 
mystic-form of drama is music-drama. I implied that Wagner 
supposed an antecedent unity and suggested a three-fold form 
for securing this unity. He initiated this three-fold develop 
ment in the modern theatre. Third paragraph, il) Misrepre- 
sents Wagner and Mr. Craig as "fundamentally opposed." 
Fundamentally Wagner is in an infinite world. Where is Mr. 
Craig? I suppose he is where his disciples are conspiring to 
put him — in their own narrow, little world. (2) Misrepresents 
Mr. Crai" as being anxious to separate the "arts" (whatever 
this pale-faced nonsense may mean). 

In one respect, at least, Wagner. Max Reinhardt, and Mr. 
Craig are on common ground. They seek the same thing — 
namely, the highest or creative dramatic effect upon the spec- 
tator. The effect which stirs the inner consciousness of the 
spectator and impels him to realise instinctively that creative 
activity which resides in and is potential in every human being. 
Both assume that everyone in the theatre has a common sensa- 
tion, the sensation produced upon all the senses by the Drama- 
vibrations. These vibrations operate upon every part of the 
whole man. and not upon one or two sense areas, as is eommonlv 
supposed. Both feel, too, that the highest dramatic effect is 
to be sought only in one direction — namely, through unity and 
the utmost efficiency of all parts of the instruments for pro 
ducing the effect. But apparently neither of them has formu- 
lated a definite theoretic basis upon which this highly sensitised 
instrument of transmission may he constructed. It seems, 
indped, as though all three are only aware of a stage in the 
construction of the instrument. As a rough illustration of what 
I mean let me lake the facts of the construction of a motor-car. 
A motor-car is mainly constructed for the purpose of transit. 
Its essentials are (n) motor spirit or potential energy (which, 
let me say. represents Drama) ; {b) an engine for converting 
the. spirit into work or achievement (the author) : (r) a gear- 
hox which changes the pnergy from the pngine to suit the 



requirements of the final effect (theatre and producing staff). 
Now, I would say that Wagner, Max Heinhardt, and Mr. 
Craig are at the gear box stage. We know that they under 
stand and work according to the principles of the gear-box. 
But there is no evidence to show that, if they have postulated 
a fundamental motion (called Drama), they have thence dpduced 
a law of the cumulative growth of all the facts of representation 
and interpretation till the ultimate effect is reached. In fact, 
there is nothing to show that they have first considered the 
origin and nature of the first thing in the order of dramatic 
sequence — that which sets up the first movement in the conscious 
entity, and which ultimately produces the creative dramatic 
effect — and thereafter set to work to trace its continuous func- 
tion and the connection between all the instruments of trans- 
mission. In fact, neither of them has thoroughly reconstructed 
the science of the theatre (as an essential part of the Drama- 
lluw) from beginning to end. The first man who gives this 
mathematical description of the theatre, who takes adequate 
measures to ascertain and regulate the sequence of events in 
the propagation of Drama-vibrations, will invent a new way of 
thinking about the theatre, as Galileo did about dynamics. He 
will reveal not only that all things in the theatre are intercon 
uected, but are based on a few simple, fundamental laws that 
can be comprehended by all men. I have had the task in mind 
for years, and now that I am returning to robust health, I 
think I will undertake it. To sum up Mr. Craig's position. 
He seeks a creative dramatic effect. He supposes th» existence 
of a fundamental something (which I will call Drama) for pro- 
ducing this effect. He is aware of a world (which I will call 
the Theatre) of the external manifestation of this something. 
He believes that all the parts of this world should be not only 
highly efficient but connected. He is experimenting with what 
he believes to be the connecting links. According as each author 
(dead or living) hands him Drama vihrations (in the form of 
a play) he divides them up into three parts, consisting of Sound. 
Motion, and Colour, answering to the three senses of the spec- 
tator— namely, hearing, touch, and sight. Doubtless he hopes 
thereby to saturate the whole of the spectator with the vibrative 
flow and achieve his creative dramatic effect. But is the effect 
complete? Apparently not, for two currents of the How — those 
operating on taste and smell, have been eliminated. In the 
Church performance of one of the highest forms of Drama, 
the Mass. all the senses are operated upon. In any case, Mr. 
Craig makes for unity, not separation. 

In his final dozen lines or so Mr. John Cournos flies in the 
face of my text, twists my meanings, confuses the relation 
between Blake and Mr. Craig, tells us that, Max Reinhardt is 
a mystic hecause he has applied Wagner's mystic-form, and 
finally disappears down a " Well ! well !" of his own contriving. 
Here for the present T v\ ill leave him. loudly proclaiming that 
of all silly fools Mr. Craig is the silliest. 

Huntlv Caktkr. 



EDITORIAL. 

Letters, &c, intended for the Editor should be 
addressed to Oakley House, Bloomsbury Street, 
London, W.C. 

PUBLICATION. 

All business comiiiuuicalions relative to the publica- 
tion of The Egoist should be addressed, and all 
cheques, postal and money orders, &c, made payable 
to The New Frekwoman, Ltd., Oakley House, 
Bloomsbury Street, London, W.C, and should be 
crossed " Parr's Bank, Bloomsbury Branch." 

Terms of Subscription. — Yearly, 13/- (U.S.A., 
3 dollars '25 cents); Six Months, 6/6 (U.S.A., 
1 dollar 63 cents); Three Months, 3/3 (U.S.A., 
S't cents). Single Copies 7d., post free to any 
address in the Postal Union. 

.4 D VERTISKMENT8. 

All orders, letters, &c., concerning advertisements 
should be addressed to the Advertisement Manager, 
The Egoist, Oakley House, Bloomsbury Street, 
London, W.C. 



All BACK NUMBERS of "THE EGOIST" and 
"THE NEW FREEWOMAN " can be obtained 
from the publishing office : Oakley House, Blooms- 
bury Street, London, W.C. Price 6d. each. By 

post, 6Ad. 



Printed by Partridge & Cooper. Ltd., Fleet Street. London, E.C., and published by the Proprietors, 
Tug \ T irw h'pcp.wn \nN. T/rn-, at Oaklev House, Bloomsbury.Street, London, W.C.